M30 - Host Sign-ups (Poll now available!)

[MacheTheFerret]

Can we have updated critiques soon or

[Julia Pseudo]

One thing I never understood bout silencing in mafia is, can you talk about non-mafia stuff to other players if two friends sign up?

Example: I have co-comme rated on both Sanct and bossedit8's videos (I know bossedit does not play mafia) and if one of us is silenced, would we also not allowed to do other actives as well? The same thing goes for Skype calls as well as the entire forum wide. Does it mean no internet access to a community related to the SMBX forums?

You're definitely still allowed to talk about non-mafia stuff when you are silenced. You are just

- not allowed to post in the game thread,
- not allowed to discuss the game on IRC and
- not allowed to PM other players about game-related matters.

Without having a set team, the Delusionist doesn't seem like a very fun role to be cast as, but it's good balance wise.
Otherwise looks good though, I appreciate the lack of many standard blue roles.

How would you recommend making the Delusionist a more interesting and fun role without making it too OP? The reason that I didn't create much more of an ability for the Delusionist is because hopefully within the first few Nights they would join a team

I would let the role choose which team to join or something like that, personally (maybe keeping their yellow cardflip for the whole game).

I feel that the May-Mays are a little underpowered compared to the town, which has both normal blues and freemasons. Although it has two town-colored members, I still think game balance would benefit from an extra ability within the mafia (on one or two of the unpowered members).

I changed one of the May-Mays into a painter; he can paint people red each night. Is that enough?

Yeah, that's great, your game is approved now.

I wanted to make a couple changes to my idea to balance the mafia and add another blue, is it okay for me to do this if my game was already approved?

That should be fine, as long as you include a changelog.

[MacheTheFerret]

Changed something about my game (well, clarified would be a better word):
When someone inherits the abilities and color of the person stated in the Vague Will, it doesn't change their team, and doesn't grant them instant knowledge of the members of the May-Mays nor the Bernie Supporters.

Ex1: If the player who is Donald Trump is stated in the will, and the owner of the will when that player dies is a May-May, the May-May will gain the ability to inspect players and turn blue, but won't become a townsperson.
Ex2: If a player who is a Bernie Supporter is stated in the will, and the owner of the will when that player dies is a May-May, the May-May will turn purple, but won't learn who the members of the Bernie Supporters are.

[PixelPest]

Without having a set team, the Delusionist doesn't seem like a very fun role to be cast as, but it's good balance wise.
Otherwise looks good though, I appreciate the lack of many standard blue roles.

How would you recommend making the Delusionist a more interesting and fun role without making it too OP? The reason that I didn't create much more of an ability for the Delusionist is because hopefully within the first few Nights they would join a team

I would let the role choose which team to join or something like that, personally (maybe keeping their yellow cardflip for the whole game).

Making them able to choose their team would ruin the point of the role, however I'll change some other things such as keeping their cardflip colour

[PersonNamedUser]

I made changes, but the changes i made may seem a little complex.

[MacheTheFerret]

It's been a couple days since the last game and game changes were posted. Could we expect the poll to go up soon?

[PersonNamedUser]

It's been a couple days since the last game and game changes were posted. Could we expect the poll to go up soon?

Spinda still needs to critique a couple of the games, which i hope he does soon.

May you please review last few games?

[MacheTheFerret]

It's been a couple days since the last game and game changes were posted. Could we expect the poll to go up soon?

Spinda still needs to critique a couple of the games, which i hope he does soon.

May you please review last few games?

I don't think Spinda needs to review it if Pseudo's got it covered, but...

[Julia Pseudo]

^
Historically, we've waited until the active GMs all reviewed all the games - probably won't be long.

[TLtimelord]

Do the Mafia have to say which of them will do the killing (so they can be seen by the Watcher)?

Guess I should clarify that too! The mafia member that tells the GM who they're gonna kill, same logic applies to the loudmouth. Although all the mafia gets exposed by the loudmouth in EpicMafia, that's not how it will work here so it can be fair & the mafia team isn't all shot out in one night.

[PersonNamedUser]

(sigh) why has Spinda critqued every game except mine?

[underFlo]

chill man i just didnt get to it yet because i was away all day

[PersonNamedUser]

The Revival potion is based on RNG way too much for my liking.
imo the dragons may work better if it were only 2
I don't get why the Mirror Wizard has a 2 night cooldown. His item is way more situational than the Orb Wizard's and their cooldowns should be swapped
Does the Green Slime choose a blue after he's died? Also, what happens if he chooses the Dark Wizard (assuming he's made his color blue)? Will nothing happen?

Maybe i could just remove the revival potion. About the dragons, i think i'll decrease it to two. I think i'll switch the Mirror Wizard and Orb Wizard's cooldowns
because what you said makes very logical sense. Also, if he targets the dark wizard when he flips as blue, i'm trying to decide if nothing should happen,
or if he should get nightkill immunity. Which makes more sense?
EDIT:
I decided that nothing happens, and how does my game look now?

[MECHDRAGON777]

I updated my game as Spinda requested.

[MacheTheFerret]

I replaced one of the Bernie Supporters with a Trump Supporter in my game, as per Spinda's request.

Considering the last anyone's updated or reviewed a game was yesterday (besides my update just now), could the poll go up soon?

[Julia Pseudo]

Sure why not.

[MacheTheFerret]

Spoiler: show

[Julia Pseudo]

Ooh, promo posters are good stuff.

Spoiler: show

[HeroOfRhyme]

And that is precisely why I didnt vote for PPX

I voted for Pseudo's game since it looks balance and neat and fun to play. I dislike all the meme garbage for this type of thing.

[Zeldamaster12]

I was stuck choosing either Kyo Saito's game or Pseudo's, but in the end, I decided to pick Pseudo.