Mafia Discussion

[Magna]

I do not think this place is used for submitting magia games anymore, correct me if i am wrong.


The blue bomber thing, i do not know how he changes the game by rigging it, and their are many things wrong with have a secret chat to reveal roles, i was in one but i quit it when they kept asking me the same question and lied about my role. Still to the point, if you got lynched or killed at the beginning of the game just be ok with it, it will get better, it is just a GAME!

I'm not using it to submit the game, I'm using it to gain popular opinion on what game people want to play.

Which is great for the game concept thread.

[zioy]

I do not think this place is used for submitting magia games anymore, correct me if i am wrong.


The blue bomber thing, i do not know how he changes the game by rigging it, and their are many things wrong with have a secret chat to reveal roles, i was in one but i quit it when they kept asking me the same question and lied about my role. Still to the point, if you got lynched or killed at the beginning of the game just be ok with it, it will get better, it is just a GAME!

I'm not using it to submit the game, I'm using it to gain popular opinion on what game people want to play.

Which is great for the game concept thread.

No, not really

[Magna]

No, not really

Please elaborate. All game concepts can be posted on the "Game Concept" thread. Even if you want opinions, you can get them on the thread where you are supposed to post the games in the first place.

[zioy]

No, not really

Please elaborate. All game concepts can be posted on the "Game Concept" thread. Even if you want opinions, you can get them on the thread where you are supposed to post the games in the first place.

Its too repetitive IMO
It could technically go to either thread tbh

[FallingSnow]

We want to try to keep the game ideas and discussion of those ideas in the other thread, so I'm agreeing with Blue Bomber on this one.

[zioy]

We want to try to keep the game ideas and discussion of those ideas in the other thread, so I'm agreeing with Blue Bomber on this one.

OK. Go ahead and move those posts related to it over then.

[Magna]

Can we make a sort of tenth anniversary game where some kind of gimmick will take place like for example:
-At least one custom role from the past nine games will be used in this game.
-Make it different from the usual games, like maybe make it a Faction game.
-After this game ends, possibly make a medal to give to the best mafia players?
-Make it so that veteran players are allowed to play only in the game.

I can name a few other ideas but I think the next game should be a special one and I also think Joey should run it, too.

[Julia Pseudo]

Topic merged, you're not really supposed to create topics here unless you're hosting a game.

Sounds like a pretty good idea to me, other than disallowing new players from joining in the game. Any user should be allowed to play, I think.

[Magna]

Topic merged, you're not really supposed to create topics here unless you're hosting a game.

Sounds like a pretty good idea to me, other than disallowing new players from joining in the game. Any user should be allowed to play, I think.

The point of the game is to make a game with 10-15 players being all veterans, allowing newbs to play would defeat the purpose of making a game of veteran players only.

[MacheTheFerret]

Topic merged, you're not really supposed to create topics here unless you're hosting a game.

Sounds like a pretty good idea to me, other than disallowing new players from joining in the game. Any user should be allowed to play, I think.

The point of the game is to make a game with 10-15 players being all veterans, allowing newbs to play would defeat the purpose of making a game of veteran players only.

What Pseudo-Dino is (super) saying is that it would be unfair and rude to players who aren't "veterans." Don't you think that's a little not fair?

[zioy]

Yeah that rule for M10 is ridiculous

[FallingSnow]

The only thing that I'm (personally) thinking about doing different next time (haven't spoken with Pseudo yet) is possibly doing two smaller matches each with 10-12 players hosted by two different people. Users can sign up for either of the matches.
(Of course this has yet to be decided and it would still depend on the community's choice of winners. If everyone still wants a large game, that's fine too)

[zioy]

The only thing that I'm (personally) thinking about doing different next time (haven't spoken with Pseudo yet) is possibly doing two smaller matches each with 10-12 players hosted by two different people. Users can sign up for either of the matches.
(Of course this has yet to be decided and it would still depend on the community's choice of winners. If everyone still wants a large game, that's fine too)

I really like this idea.
I'd prefer for there to be one smaller match and one slightly larger one (a 12-player and a 15-player?)
And have an M# series game and an A# game series (A for alternate)

[FallingSnow]

My only concern as of right now is the number or potential players. If there are enough players for a larger game and a smaller game, there would be no problem doing that.

[Danny]

The only thing that I'm (personally) thinking about doing different next time (haven't spoken with Pseudo yet) is possibly doing two smaller matches each with 10-12 players hosted by two different people. Users can sign up for either of the matches.
(Of course this has yet to be decided and it would still depend on the community's choice of winners. If everyone still wants a large game, that's fine too)

I really like this idea.
I'd prefer for there to be one smaller match and one slightly larger one (a 12-player and a 15-player?)
And have an M# series game and an A# game series (A for alternate)

I like this idea.

KoolKat, it would probably be M# and AM#, AM being Alternate Mafia.

[Bomber57]

The only thing that I'm (personally) thinking about doing different next time (haven't spoken with Pseudo yet) is possibly doing two smaller matches each with 10-12 players hosted by two different people. Users can sign up for either of the matches.
(Of course this has yet to be decided and it would still depend on the community's choice of winners. If everyone still wants a large game, that's fine too)

I really like this idea.
I'd prefer for there to be one smaller match and one slightly larger one (a 12-player and a 15-player?)
And have an M# series game and an A# game series (A for alternate)

I like this idea.

KoolKat, it would probably be M# and AM#, AM being Alternate Mafia.

We'll have to set it forward an hour come next daylight savings ::)

[Magna]

The only thing that I'm (personally) thinking about doing different next time (haven't spoken with Pseudo yet) is possibly doing two smaller matches each with 10-12 players hosted by two different people. Users can sign up for either of the matches.
(Of course this has yet to be decided and it would still depend on the community's choice of winners. If everyone still wants a large game, that's fine too)

This isn't a good idea. If you sign up for both games, you will have to keep up with both of them.

Why not host a single 15 player veteran-only game to see 15 experienced people play together? How is that more entertaining than noobs playing in two games at once and make it seem like two normal games.

[FallingSnow]

"Either" implies one not both.

[MistakesWereMade]

The only thing that I'm (personally) thinking about doing different next time (haven't spoken with Pseudo yet) is possibly doing two smaller matches each with 10-12 players hosted by two different people. Users can sign up for either of the matches.
(Of course this has yet to be decided and it would still depend on the community's choice of winners. If everyone still wants a large game, that's fine too)

This isn't a good idea. If you sign up for both games, you will have to keep up with both of them.

Why not host a single 15 player veteran-only game to see 15 experienced people play together? How is that more entertaining than noobs playing in two games at once and make it seem like two normal games.

>implying there's a functional way to know who's a veteran

>implying that, even if we knew who's veteran and who's a "noob", there's enough players of each "class" for each game.

[Magna]

By "veteran" I mean someone who played in at least a total of 3-5 games.