M4: 'The Best Mafia Game'

[Marina]

I vote to lynch Joey bc bandwagons are fun.

[zlaker]

I vote for Joey

[qig]

Joey - 5
Blue Dread - 3
Murphmario - 2

[TheLordKhon]

i vote blue dread

[TheLordKhon]

oops mindfuck i meant Blue dread

[Bomber57]

I vote for Blue Dread.

[The Wizard of Off]

oops mindfuck i meant Blue dread

why are you voting blue dread I mean he hasnt done anything wrong also he is our only lead here what if the sheriff really did tell him maybe hes the only one he trusts

[Ignoritus]

oops mindfuck i meant Blue dread

why are you voting blue dread I mean he hasnt done anything wrong also he is our only lead here what if the sheriff really did tell him maybe hes the only one he trusts

If the Sheriff did decide to trust him, all that tells us is that we can't trust the Sheriff this game to make good decisions. If what Blue Dread said is true, the Sheriff inspected MurphMario and he turned up green. Why in HELL would the Sheriff then go ahead and tell his role to some random person when he KNEW MurphMario was safe? The only way this whole story makes sense is if Blue Dread himself is the Sheriff and lied to protect MurphMario without revealing himself. However, we can't not lynch him on this basis as if he's NOT the Sheriff we're letting a Mafia get away, and if he IS the Sheriff the Mafia themselves no doubt realize that at this point and will murder him tonight anyways. Or even if they didn't realize that, they would have murdered him anyways as that forces the Sheriff to put their trust in someone else.

In short, the only situation in which Blue Dread survives this day and night is if he IS Mafia and we don't lynch him. We have no reason not to leave that opening seeing as we have no better leads than "Murphmario sounded suspicious" and "Joey said something that a bunch of people misread as him wanting the Sheriff to publicly reveal themselves (which he clearly said he didn't want), let's lynch him".

[qig]

Joey - 5
Blue Dread - 5
Murphmario - 2

oh boy a tie how exciting. 2 more votes are needed for Joey or Blue Dread for an insta.

[The Wizard of Off]

well maybe the sheriff trusted blue dread more than murphmario because little boo accused murphmario to be something and murphmario thought that it was dangerous for him if little boo stayed alive so he trusted blue dread, he might still be suspicious of that murphmario is the godfather but we cant know that

[FallingSnow]

We must not allow a loose cannon like that fellow Blue Dread to impede our progress in the lynchings of mafia members. His sly manipulation and quickness to change his vote make hims a dangerous fellow to keep milling about. He's a threat to our sheriff in his current state, and I fear what may unfold if the two of them have indeed made contact. Only time may tell the truth of our predicament.

[Magna]

I am not the sheriff, the sheriff simply came to me because he knows that I can't be trusted and will use his finding for the good of this town. And again, I may have made mistakes in the past, but that is no reason to think I am scheming something that would put the town in a bad position.

If you guys kill me, you will just lose an great opportunity.
In fact, I know the roles of 9 out of the 15 players playing. I know I may be hiding a lot of my info, but I have a secret channel on the irc where I share some of my secrets to only people I can trust. You have to figure out yourself what channel it is.

[Magna]

I feel as if some of these votes may be biased, too.

For the past three mafia games, I was always the central target for lynching. Why? Did I do something? Am I just acting suspicious? Is it just in my nature to be suspicious and the central target? Give me a break guys. If you wanna lynch me, please lynch me for a good reason, not because of bandwagon.

[Ignoritus]

I am not the sheriff, the sheriff simply came to me because he knows that I can't be trusted and will use his finding for the good of this town.

Then the Sheriff is making very poor decisions, choosing to trust someone turn one off of no evidence after finding a green he could trust.

In fact, I know the roles of 9 out of the 15 players playing.

This is in fact bull. I'm not sure it's possible for you to know for sure the role of ONE still alive player at this point, and I know for a fact that saying you know 9 is bullshit.

Either you're straight up making it up to avoid being lynched, or you're doing the M2 thing again where people make bold claims that they state they have "proof of" or that they "know" something, get innocents lynched, and then reveal that your methods of "knowing" or your "proof" was broken logistics or suspicions.

[Magna]

I am not the sheriff, the sheriff simply came to me because he knows that I can't be trusted and will use his finding for the good of this town.

Then the Sheriff is making very poor decisions, choosing to trust someone turn one off of no evidence after finding a green he could trust.

In fact, I know the roles of 9 out of the 15 players playing.

This is in fact bull. I'm not sure it's possible for you to know for sure the role of ONE still alive player at this point, and I know for a fact that saying you know 9 is bull.

Either you're straight up making it up, or you're doing the M2 thing again where people make bold claims that they state they have "proof of" or that they "know" something, get innocents lynched, and then reveal that your methods of "knowing" or your "proof" was broken logistics or suspicions.

Nope, not bullshitting, not even close. I really do know 9 roles of all people playing. I can't reveal them yet because it would be bad for the town.

[Bomber57]

I am not the sheriff, the sheriff simply came to me because he knows that I can't be trusted and will use his finding for the good of this town.

Then the Sheriff is making very poor decisions, choosing to trust someone turn one off of no evidence after finding a green he could trust.

In fact, I know the roles of 9 out of the 15 players playing.

This is in fact bull. I'm not sure it's possible for you to know for sure the role of ONE still alive player at this point, and I know for a fact that saying you know 9 is bull.

Either you're straight up making it up, or you're doing the M2 thing again where people make bold claims that they state they have "proof of" or that they "know" something, get innocents lynched, and then reveal that your methods of "knowing" or your "proof" was broken logistics or suspicions.

Nope, not bullshitting, not even close. I really do know 9 roles of all people playing. I can't reveal them yet because it would be bad for the town.

How the hell do you 100% know 9 roles after 1 goddamn night. That's a really big stretch.

[Ignoritus]

Nope, not bullshitting, not even close. I really do know 9 roles of all people playing. I can't reveal them yet because it would be bad for the town.

How the hell do you 100% know 9 roles after 1 goddamn night. That's a really big stretch.

He doesn't. It's actually not possible unless he wants to convince me 9 people showed him screenshots of their role PMs (which isn't even allowed iirc). There's not enough information lurking for him to have discovered those roles logically, and the only other thing he could really have is word of mouth.

[Magna]

How the hell do you 100% know 9 roles after 1 goddamn night. That's a really big stretch.

Well, it is more time than you think, really. And I don't 100% know. The people who told me may be lying when they told me, but I trust them enough to believe them. And it fits well, too.

I wish I could prove it, but I'm afraid one of you may use it for your own dirty deeds. But if I must, I would have to choose one person, and have him confirm to everyone I wasn't bullshitting because I told him privately. I really don't know which of you who are accusing me to tell it too.

[Murphmario]

I vote for Joey. In one of his posts, he said that the 3rd option was most beneficial, when honestly it was the 2nd one. Obvious Mafia point right there.

Blue Dread, I'll leave you alone for now. Thanks for defending me.

[qig]

Your vote needs to be bold and red.