M4: 'The Best Mafia Game'

[Magna]

I dont think we should lynch blue dread he so far he is our only lead so what if he is telling the truth then we lynch him we have no other lead

Plus, I know more than you expect. I may even know some roles of some of the members. I may be valuable at this moment in time and lynching me will blow your chances of using my intelligence.

So why not share your information? This is incredibly suspicious.

Because it will risk the lives of those people I know the roles of! Only people I can trust I can reveal my info. And not just for fun either. I would only reveal if it was important to for the moment.

This is exactly why I just voted you to be lynched.

[qig]

To answer a question posted earlier, The Vigilante will get notified if/when they successfully use their ability.

[Bomber57]

Blue Dread, just because he wants information doesn't automatically make him anti-town. You'd need a little more evidence before I or anyone else believes you.

[qig]

On that note, here are the current lynch votes.
Blue Dread: 3
Joey: 2

[The Wizard of Off]

come on does joey not seem suspicious to anyone else? hes been targeting blue dread the hole time

[Bomber57]

come on does joey not seem suspicious to anyone else? hes been targeting blue dread the hole time

And he has been targeting Joey the whole time. Your point is moot.

[The Wizard of Off]

come on does joey not seem suspicious to anyone else? hes been targeting blue dread the hole time

And he has been targeting Joey the whole time. Your point is moot.

even if my point is moot I am still on Blue dreads side of the argument

[Magna]

come on does joey not seem suspicious to anyone else? hes been targeting blue dread the hole time

And he has been targeting Joey the whole time. Your point is moot.

Why do you attack me specifically? Unless you and Joey are Mafia, I don't see why you would be defending each other. I'm voting Joey off because he is asking for the sheriff to be revealed. You and I both know that is a careless act.

[Bomber57]

come on does joey not seem suspicious to anyone else? hes been targeting blue dread the hole time

And he has been targeting Joey the whole time. Your point is moot.

Why do you attack me specifically? Unless you and Joey are Mafia, I don't see why you would be defending each other. I'm voting Joey off because he is asking for the sheriff to be revealed. You and I both know that is a careless act.

I'm not attacking you. I am making sure you guys don't make pointless lynches like you did in M2.

[Magna]

Then you should be attacking Igno and Snow.

[Ignoritus]

Then you should be attacking Igno and Snow.

For what? Choosing someone who had a history of doing poorly in this game for our random lynch? For the record, when new information came out I would have changed my vote if that information then pointed to someone other than you. But the new information has honestly done nothing but encourage me to lynch you despite it having started as a random lynch.

If we have to randomly lynch someone without much information, we're not going to choose someone who has a very clear idea of how to play this game. We're going to lynch someone who has shown that they encourage poor decisions. Sorry, but it's true. And now that we do have information, you are the one responsible for making yourself look suspicious.

[Julia Pseudo]

Murphmario seems especially suspicious to me based on his comments. I vote to lynch him.

[TLtimelord]

I'm voting Joey because his carelessness about a townsperson dying to the Jester as well as him not at all worried about the Vigi dying if he revealed his role raises a red flag. It's almost as if killing off townspeople won't affect him at all.

[Magna]

I'm voting Joey because his carelessness about a townsperson dying to the Jester as well as him not at all worried about the Vigi dying if he revealed his role raises a red flag. It's almost as if killing off townspeople won't affect him at all.

He especially wants to know the roles of the special people, especially the sheriff because he knows I know who the sheriff is. Only mafia or the serial killer would want to know who the Blues are so they can murder them.

[Bomber57]

I'm voting Joey because his carelessness about a townsperson dying to the Jester as well as him not at all worried about the Vigi dying if he revealed his role raises a red flag. It's almost as if killing off townspeople won't affect him at all.

He especially wants to know the roles of the special people, especially the sheriff because he knows I know who the sheriff is. Only mafia or the serial killer would want to know who the Blues are so they can murder them.

Not exactly the case. Townspeople or other blues might want to know who the Sheriff is so they can better collaborate with him.

I say we should just let the day pass through without lynching and allow a second night phase to allow us to gather our thoughts and further information.

[Karl Marx]

Sorry I was out of town all afternoon, seems things really have shaken up...

While both Blue Dread and Joey both do seem suspicious in their thirst for knowledge of who's who or whatever, my vote is on Murphmario, primarily because his insistence on his innocence over and over again is getting a little stale.

You know where to look when somebody out of the blue insists they didn't do it

[qig]

Blue Dread - 3
Joey - 3
Murphmario - 2

Here are the current lynch numbers. Seven (and a post from the person in question) are needed for an insta.

[zlaker]

I'm voting Joey because his carelessness about a townsperson dying to the Jester as well as him not at all worried about the Vigi dying if he revealed his role raises a red flag. It's almost as if killing off townspeople won't affect him at all.

He especially wants to know the roles of the special people, especially the sheriff because he knows I know who the sheriff is. Only mafia or the serial killer would want to know who the Blues are so they can murder them.

If ya know the sheriff why don't make him inspect Joey to learn his color so he could tell ya it :/

[Magna]

I'm voting Joey because his carelessness about a townsperson dying to the Jester as well as him not at all worried about the Vigi dying if he revealed his role raises a red flag. It's almost as if killing off townspeople won't affect him at all.

He especially wants to know the roles of the special people, especially the sheriff because he knows I know who the sheriff is. Only mafia or the serial killer would want to know who the Blues are so they can murder them.

If ya know the sheriff why don't make him inspect Joey to learn his color so he could tell ya it :/

Well, he told me he was gonna do that tonight, he thinks Joey should be inspected because he thinks Joey is suspicous, too.

[Magna]

I will even show everyone the quote of the sheriff when he tells me his results. An exact cut and paste.