M16: The Best of Both Worlds - MAFIA VICTORY

[Danny]

Well the jouor is said by joey, is useless, so they kill him of then boom, easy game to kill everyoneand cancel stuff out. Also ppx was being ppx, but that was suspicious, but i will not cast a vote till mote votes come up.

Yes, the Doublevoter roles are kind of useless I guess, but why would the Mafia kill one of their own kind to... make for an easy game and cancel stuff out...? That literally makes no sense, I doubt the Mafia would kill their own teammate to "make the game easier". The more Mafia on the Mafia team, the better for them, because the Mafia can only win when their numbers are equal to the number of Town members and if the Serial Killer is dead, the less members they have the more likely they are to lose. So useless role or not, to be fair it actually helps a lot because it's not their powers that really matter, it's the numbers. So while the Doublevoter's ability may seem useless, him being alive just helps the town because we have one more person alive on our side.

No Read
zlakergirl357
Ragont
BlimpFruit
GLD4
Waddle Derp
Nien
RudeGuy07
Frozen Boo
TheLordKhon
The Wizard of Off

Not Suspicious
Zeldamaster12 - Doublevoter, essentially confirmed.
Mivixion - I exist.

Notable (Like no read, but have contributed)
8bitmushroom
Choco
Karl Marx

Maybe you can explain your suspicion list a little better? Like what is "No Read", "Not Suspicious", and "Notable" supposed to mean? If it means who has read the thread or not, I wouldn't go solely on that to be suspicious of people.

Also voting Bloodedge due to suspicions on him.

[Sevennights]

Well, why lynch me other then my paranoia!? Yes i dissagree with the alliance becaise of people lying about there roles, which is true ok sir, people might have lied to zm aboit there role. Now, people suspect me by the way i act, look at past games, always paranoid, but this game i am really paranoid and i just think of all of the way of what could happen. I think i am over thinking it but man, just think about everything that could happen! Still not gonna place a vote becaise of no suspicion to others, other then ppx or zm lying about role 24%... and place make sure about the roles there zm.

[Shadow Yoshi]

Bloodedge: If the alliance leader receives a single claim for a special role (the doctor, for example) and the claimer is lying, it means that the REAL doctor for whatever reason didn't step up and claim to the alliance leader. The doctor has no reason to not claim to the alliance leader (ZM) because the alliance leader is a confirmed human.

[Sevennights]

Okle t me give on example...
Let us say nickname is the sheriff but never told zm his role because he did not want to tell him his role and a mafia said there the sheriff, then most of the blue would be found out and they would die, making gme harder.

Or how about this, doctor is inactive, someone claims doctor to zm, kills nickname, finds out rest of blues, blue killing rampage. Think about.it a bit more sir.

[Zeldamaster12]

I know that Bloodedge is always this way in Mafia, but he's acting like it in a different way than usual. He's the only one who disagrees about having an alliance, and he refuses to believe I'm the Doublevoter, even when it's already been confirmed.

Changing vote from PaperPlayerX to Bloodedge

[Shadow Yoshi]

but never told zm his role because he did not want to tell him his role

Except he has no reason not to tell ZM since ZM is a confirmed human.

Or how about this, doctor is inactive, someone claims doctor to zm

But this can only happen if we have inactive players to begin with.

[Sevennights]

We have quite a few inactive players,
Now confirmed human? Please explaon that.

[Zeldamaster12]

I claimed Doublevoter; nobody counterclaimed.

[Danny]

Uh I could have swore there was a post by somebody else after Joey's so maybe somebody deleted their post or am I just imagining things?

Also we don't really have any inactive players? It's Day 1, and it's 11:00 PM EST. Everyone, on Night 1, spoke up when Nickname asked if anyone was going to counterclaim Doublevoter. We have no inactive players, just because they don't post every single minute does not mean they're inactive.

[zlaker]

Cya Bloodedge.

[Karl Marx]

Yeah I don't believe Zeldamaster12. Saying you're the double voter and that nobody countered that is a completely illogical assertion, that's like saying the sun is blue because I said it and nobody countered me.

[Danny]

Yeah I don't believe Zeldamaster12. Saying you're the double voter and that nobody countered that is a completely illogical assertion, that's like saying the sun is blue because I said it and nobody countered me.

But the Doublevoter is a special that we can risk losing because although it doesn't benefit us much anyhow, it still gives somebody a higher state of authority because they have a blue role. Since the role is pretty useless in itself it would make sense to use it for the town's good. We wouldn't be trusting Zeldamaster if he wasn't the only one who claimed to be the Doublevoter, but he is the only one that has claimed that role. The Doublevoter is somebody who, quite honestly, won't really debilitate us if we lose them, so it would only make sense to have them lead the town as they can easily be trusted and the other Town specials can easily get in contact with each other through that role.

Though yes I agree on Night 1 it is kind of strange to roleclaim as a special, this may help us out in the long run in finding out who the Mafia and Serial Killer are and collaborating with the rest of the specials. If someone else was truly the Doublevoter, I'm sure they would have said something as it isn't really a risk to lose the Doublevoter at a time like this, though the Doublevoter will help us, if that makes sense. I'm choosing to trust Zeldamaster as the Doublevoter because he's the only one that claimed he is that role.

However now that I think about it, on the contrary, Nickname was a special role, and he supposedly got in contact with Zeldamaster as far as I'm aware (though I could be wrong so don't hold this against me), and Nickname was killed on Night 1, so there is the possibility that Zeldamaster isn't actually the Doublevoter, and from what I've seen so far people are saying Nickname was the Sheriff, which is a major blow to the town.

I'm keeping my vote on Bloodedge right now though because he has been saying a few strange things, and although he does that every Mafia game, he's been acting off-key. Unless something else happens my vote won't go to Zeldamaster just yet.

[Zeldamaster12]

Okay, I'm going to put myself in a Mafioso's shoes for a second.

If I were to find out Nickname, why would I kill him instantly? That'd be way too obvious, and I'm smarter than that.

Anyways, I think I've done enough to prove myself, since you know, nobody out of the 20 players counterclaimed. If I wasn't the Doublevoter, and the real one saw that I was being a false leader, why wouldn't they claim to prove me wrong?

You gotta think about all this.

[Zeldamaster12]

Also for the record, I wouldn't have claimed Night 1 if Joey hadn't have came up with this strategy.

[Valentine]

I don't like that you guys are trusting ZM this easily but there's no real way to disprove him for now. So i just won't vote for anyone ok?

[Waddle]

I see why you guys suspect Zeldamaster, but Bloodedge is very suspicious too.
Also, not voting isn't allowed anymore, right?
Bloodedge

[Danny]

Voting for Safety isn't allowed anymore, you can still choose to vote for nobody.

[Zeldamaster12]

I don't know what else I can do to prove myself. Trust me or don't, but if you aim to get rid of me, then you're making a mistake.

[Valentine]

I don't know what else I can do to prove myself. Trust me or don't, but if you aim to get rid of me, then you're making a mistake.

i said there isn't any evidence AGAINST you, but i have some suspicions on a couple of people. And it's usually hard to get my trust

[Choco]

good job

you set a record for first spambot in a mafia game

Anyway, Bloodedge does seem pretty suspicious, even more than normal.