M12: Night... of the Mafia - TOWN VICTORY

[Julia Pseudo]

Hey everyone, when you write that you're changing your vote it's really helpful if you list the player you were originally lynching as well as the new one, like FallingSnow did.

Anyhoo, the current numbers:
8bitmushroom: 2
Nickname: 2
Safety: 1

[FallingSnow]

I suspect you because you are, in general, very shady.

Because I don't want to participate in your dumb arguments with nickname?

Popping in just to make lynch votes

So I don't get phantoms.

and plus there i almost no one else I can suspect of being the SK. I know who 9-10 of the 15 roles are.

If you say so. Still not serial killer, though.

[HeroOfRhyme]

I forgot about 8bit's vote. Perfect hey, I was thinking it was 2-1-1 not 2-2-1. That stalls to a kitb at the least. We just need another vote, or FallingSnow's on Nickname. I'm just hoping this is a good move taking Nickname out.


Also "dumb arguments with nickname" i find really funny because there was no arguments, and nickname and I havent posted directly at one another for at least 3 pages so that is pretty bad reasoning.

Phantom votes, Pseudo said there wasnt a phantom system in place for this game, and I know someone else who isnt voting. That's another bad reasoning, although it's reasonable to a point.

Also that last point is just denial because you dont want to publicly announce it. I will only truly believe it when I see it. Until them my vote sits on Nickname. He's the main priority right now.

[FallingSnow]

I swear mafia has turned into a "you're wrong no you're wrong" match in this community.

I think that sums up your conversation with Nickname and is why I didn't participate. Also given that "three pages ago" was in the passed 24 hours, I feel that it is still relevant. So don't give that "it was ages ago" excuse because it wasn't.

As far as phantoms, yes, I see that he didn't put in place a specific system for them, but the general concept of inactivity exists in all games of mafia.

And denial? ;P

[Julia Pseudo]

Yes, I would like to reiterate that while there is no official phantom system in place, you should generally vote to not be seen as inactive.

[HeroOfRhyme]

no, FallingSnow, you're wrong I think that it shouldnt count, my reason to that is because we eventually came to a stalemate. I just went with his vote toward Danny til Danny told me his role. Then I changed to Nickname providing my evidence and support.

Also, that's true. Doesnt mean one night means auto kick.. You're trying to make the most of the lynches so you make sure they die and you get one step closer to the end.

And yes denial.

I'll end it there. I cant say anything else 'til night because this lynch is important. Either a red or a blue is gone. If I die tonight, though. Make sure that you guys lynch RudeGuy or FallingSnow.

RudeGuy is my guess for the other red, assuming Nickname is the Witch afterall.

[FallingSnow]

Well, now that you've said that, the SK or Mafia will likely target you just so that we (Rudeguy and I) are easy suspects in the lynch tomorrow.

Also changing vote from safety to 8bitmushroom since he told me he's a Freemason and you act as if you just learned of his roll, making that almost surely not the case.

[Julia Pseudo]

DAY 2 has ended!

The townspeople again gathered on the main road to discuss the recent deaths in the town. Although it was not initially clear who was suspicious, the town eventually agreed that 8bitmushroom must be a member of the mafia. They thew him to the the ground and proceeded to stone him to death.
8bitmushroom has died!

It is now NIGHT 3! Night 3 will end at 8:00 PM PST, December 17.

[TLtimelord]

I knew it was a bad idea to lynch 8bit.

Bear in mind, targeting nickname out of spite isn't a wise idea. Just thought I'd throw that bit of knowledge.

[FallingSnow]

Ugh, why did he lie to me?

[HeroOfRhyme]

Why would you lynch him? I told you to change to Nickname. God damn it, now our doctor is gone.

Layla, Nickname is red. My evidence still stood backing up much more than 8bit. I knew he was the doctor. He told you he was a freemason because he accidentally slipped his real role to you, and had to cover it up.

In closing, I'd like to say that I wasnt hoping for his death, and if it was his death, at least it would've been a KitB. But FallingSnow, regardless of Freemason/Doctor. He was still guaranteed town, so that puts it on you for killing him. And saving Nickname. At least if he's gone and is the Witch, we only have one more red that has to be the godfather.

That was such a bad move. And apologies if that just came off as demanding or whatnot.

[underFlo]

I hope you understand that 8bit was suspicious since he even lied about what he acts ally said back then. He said it was extremely likely that Thug and Consort died and didn't even seem to consider the Witch and Godfather having died. He then quickly rowed back and right before he died he said that only two reds have died. Pretty suspicious imo.

As for who I suspect now, it depends on how likely you think your list is, Gohan. If you're really certain it's right, we should kill RudeGuy07 who's the last Mafia if you're right, and he's also more dangerous then the SK (who is FallingSnow according to your list, which makes sense since lynching was about the only thing he did - much like he didn't want us to notice him) since he has a special power aside from killing compared to the SK. So I'd say we lynch RudeGuy07 next day and FallingSnow the day after.

[HeroOfRhyme]

Nothing is 100%. If everything goes right, then.. Both will be dead by next day. We should win. You have to understand my reasoning for lynching you, Witch or not. It would've been severely better than what happened with Danny.

[underFlo]

Afaik you never said Danny was innocent while I was still on, so I couldn't have known better.

[HeroOfRhyme]

Afaik you never said Danny was innocent while I was still on, so I couldn't have known better.

I didn't find out his role until after you had left.

[underFlo]

Oh, ok.

Also, is it just me or is this round really inactive? I didn't hear anything of zlakergirl, RudeGuy or DatDude recently. Inactivity can be really bad in a Mafia game, and I want everyone to at least participate in some way.

[DatDude]

Aaaand he had to be a blue! Also Nickname, I'm right here.

[underFlo]

Aaaand he had to be a blue! Also Nickname, I'm right here.

You nevee contributed anything though.

[HeroOfRhyme]

Because he's just a plain townsperson and probably wants to be useless. Lol, as for zlakergirl. I dunno. RudeGuy has said something, but he might be staying out of it because he's mafia.

[underFlo]

Imo if you're a townsperson you should contribute more in discussions since if you die it doesn't matter too much.