M5: Playing with Fire (POSTGAME)

[TLtimelord]

M5 - Playing with Fire

Townspeople won!

Mafia:
-Mafioso - zlakerboy357
-Mafioso - Jacob9300Shadow
-Bartender - SonGohanssj2
-Arsonist - FallingSnow

Townspeople:
-Sheriff - Ignoritus
-Deputy - Pseudo-Dino
-Lookout - KoolKat
-Firefighter - GLDude
-Townsperson - Bomber57 (Volunteer Firefighter)
-Townsperson - Blue Dread
-Townsperson - PaperPlayerX
-Townsperson - Karl Marx
-Townsperson - The Wizard of Off
-Townsperson - qig
-Townsperson - Little Boo
-Townsperson - GLuigiX
-Townsperson - Murphmario
-Townsperson - SnifitGuy
-Miller - Nien
-Millwright - HenryRichard (Volunteer Firefighter)

Character Analysis:
(They'll be rather short as I don't have much to say for most of you.

Spoiler: show

zlakerboy357 - You did a fair job keeping yourself hidden right up to the end where you were randomly bandwagonned and you didn't even send me a vote!
Jacob9300Shadow - I'd say the same that I said for zlaker, but when you started getting suspected, you didn't handle it well.
SonGohanssj2 - If you were less noisy, I'm sure you wouldn't have died so quickly. You made one or two fatal mistakes, but you managed to take out the Firefighter with you.
FallingSnow - I honestly wish things would have worked out better and you could have been more devastating! I don't really remember much but I knew you would be screwed early on because you were inspected the first night.
Ignoritus- There must have been a close call for you at least EVERY night, as you were targeted more than a couple times. Zlaker actually changed his killing vote once on me.
Pseudo-Dino - I didn't see you do much other than vote to lynch a couple days. Be more active!
KoolKat - You made one smart spying choice before you died. I'm sure you would have turned out as a good lookout.
GLDude - I have literally nothing to say about you since you entered halfway through the first night before dying anyways
Bomber57 - You were one out of maybe 4 that actually used the visiting mechanic EVERY night. One night, it even greatly benefitted the townspeople. Nice job during the night phases
Blue Dread - You died the first night, not much to say about you.
Karl Marx - You really didn't do much except have to defend yourself maybe once
The Wizard of Off - Probably my most productive townsperson next to PaperplayerX. You visited each night and voted each day.
PaperPlayerX - Same as Wizard. Although, you were rather quick to judging and voting. If it weren't for Igno's wits and your pure luck, you probably would have died quickly via lynching
qig - I know you were fairly active in the game, but I don't remember much. Still, I was aware you did things
Little Boo - I'd say you were about the same as Paper and Wizard. You voted each day and visited. Pretty regular if you ask me.
GLuigiX - I doubt you knew you were even playing because you didn't do ANYTHING at ALL.
Murphmario - I think I saw you claim townsperson once. Be more active!
SnifitGuy - Wish you could have asked more questions because it appears you never knew what you were doing.
Nien - Tough luck being the miller. Your own personal allies even turned on you!
HenryRichard - You acted as a good Firefighter follow-up, since GLDude chose you as the next leader when he died. You protected Pseudo every night just in case the mafia tried to kill him.

A few people were very good at being active and visiting, but most of you didn't do too much and you had to rely on luck and the anonymous yet obvious sheriff.

I'll claim responsibility for not staying on top of people when it came to visits and lynch votes, mostly since the arsonist died early, but I'll also blame my incredibly strict schedule, because of school and all. Any other way, the townspeople somehow got lucky with bandwagons this time around, as I still haven't a damn clue where the basis behind FallingSnow's or zlakerboy357's lynchings came from.

[Magna]

I fucking new Ignoritus was the sheriff god damnit.

[MacheTheFerret]

Jacob actually WAS a Mafia! I think now is probably a good time to say...

I FRIGGIN TOLD YOU SO!!!

I was a townie, innocent, and other stuff I was right about.
Now now, there's no need to worship me. Oh stop it you!

[zioy]

M5 - Playing with Fire

Townspeople won!

Mafia:
-Mafioso - zlakerboy357
-Mafioso - Jacob9300Shadow
-Bartender - SonGohanssj2
-Arsonist - FallingSnow

Townspeople:
-Sheriff - Ignoritus
-Deputy - Pseudo-Dino
-Lookout - Koolkat
-Firefighter - GLDude
-Townsperson - Bomber57 (Volunteer Firefighter)
-Townsperson - Blue Dread
-Townsperson - PaperPlayerX
-Townsperson - Karl Marx
-Townsperson - The Wizard of Off
-Townsperson - qig
-Townsperson - Little Boo
-Townsperson - GLuigiX
-Townsperson - Murphmario
-Townsperson - SnifitGuy
-Miller - Nien
-Millwright - HenryRichard (Volunteer Firefighter)

I'll do Analyses later.

I was literally right about 90% of these roles, no joke. The two I didn't know were qig and Nien (I thought qig was the Miller and Nien a Mafioso at first)

The Mafia discovered my role because

and then Gohan said:

<Gohan> koolkat is the real lookout
<Gohan> thats the only way he'd know

Basically, I figured out a bunch of roles while I was dead. I figured out Igno was the Sheriff through common deduction techniques. My death was a result of this message:

<koolkat> I know a Mafioso!
[quits]






ANYWAY, TNT will you please at least properly capitalize my username?

[MacheTheFerret]

Durn, Koolkat, that was very unfortunate.

[zioy]

Durn, Koolkat, that was very unfortunate.

Yeah.... anyway, I'm surprised the Mafia didn't kill Pseudo after killing me. I guess they figured someone else was more of a threat to them.

[MacheTheFerret]

I was surprised that I didn't die. I, for the most, part, not only hit the nail on the head with a few of the Mafiosi, but also generated suspicion towards myself and stuff. I think I was actually really close to death at one point, but...I forget when that happened.

[zioy]

I was surprised that I didn't die. I, for the most, part, not only hit the nail on the head with a few of the Mafiosi, but also generated suspicion towards myself and stuff. I think I was actually really close to death at one point, but...I forget when that happened.

Then Igno presented an argument against Nien, so I guess you're lucky that Nien acted so suspicious. I thought you were Mafia at first, but I figured that there was a more broad scheme going on, with the Mafia trying to frame you.


Everything else, I was right about.

[Magna]

Guys just so you know, I knew 95% of the roles even though I'm dead. only about 10% were from Gohan telling me.

[MacheTheFerret]

I was surprised that I didn't die. I, for the most, part, not only hit the nail on the head with a few of the Mafiosi, but also generated suspicion towards myself and stuff. I think I was actually really close to death at one point, but...I forget when that happened.

Then Igno presented an argument against Nien, so I guess you're lucky that Nien acted so suspicious. I thought you were Mafia at first, but I figured that there was a more broad scheme going on, with the Mafia trying to frame you.


Everything else, I was right about.

Therefore, Nien was Nien and therefore he died.

[zioy]

I was surprised that I didn't die. I, for the most, part, not only hit the nail on the head with a few of the Mafiosi, but also generated suspicion towards myself and stuff. I think I was actually really close to death at one point, but...I forget when that happened.

Then Igno presented an argument against Nien, so I guess you're lucky that Nien acted so suspicious. I thought you were Mafia at first, but I figured that there was a more broad scheme going on, with the Mafia trying to frame you.


Everything else, I was right about.

Therefore, Nien was Nien and therefore he died.

Nien's suspicion from me was mostly bias, actually. He was sort of a jerk to me back on Knux's.

[MacheTheFerret]

That is completely understandable, considering he told me to go Alt+F4 myself.

[zioy]

That is completely understandable, considering he told me to go Alt+F4 myself.

Yeah, I'm surprised he wasn't warned for something he said back on Knux's to me as well.....

[MacheTheFerret]

That is completely understandable, considering he told me to go Alt+F4 myself.

Yeah, I'm surprised he wasn't warned for something he said back on Knux's to me as well.....

You know I wouldn't be surprised if after I post this comment that Nien will say something snarky and inappropriate.


Wait...so how exactly did we go from Post-Mafia to Nien?

[FallingSnow]

I regret listening to my team and not burning Igno's house night 1.

[zioy]

B/c Nien.

Anyway, on-topic, I can't wait for M6, because either me or Dread will be hosting it.

[MacheTheFerret]

I wish I could be hosting my game on it....

[zioy]

I wish I could be hosting my game on it....

NEVAH, because I was the Lookout.

[MacheTheFerret]

I wish I could be hosting my game on it....

NEVAH, because I was the Lookout.

A connection between those two things.
I found none.

[zioy]

If you didn't you evidently forget that we were talking about Mafia.