M4: 'The Best Mafia Game' POSTGAME

[qig]

THE WINNER IS IGNORITUS THE SERIAL KILLER!!!! CONGRATS!! WOW!!!!
First off, here are the roles.
Consort: Pseudo-Dino
Godfather: Blue Dread
Janitor: Karl Marx
Jester: Little Boo
Serial Killer: Ignoritus
Miller: zlakerboy357
Townsperson: Joey
Townsperson: Fallingsnow26
Townsperson: MurphMario
Townsperson: Raster
Townsperson: Bomber57
Veteran: GLuigiX
Vigilante: TNTtimelord
Doctor: TheLordKhon
Sheriff: The Wizard of Off

and now for some rewards.

MOST VALUABLE PLAYERS: THE 9 PEOPLE WHO ENDED UP GIVING THEIR ROLE AWAY TO THE GOD FATHER BY LIKE DAY 1. CONGRATS!
BIGGEST PLAY: THE REMAINING MAFIA MEMBERS DECIDING TO PAY A VISIT TO THE SERIAL KILLER ON THE LAST DAY KILLING BOTH OF THEMSELVES. (hint ability usage is optional lololol)
BIGGEST MISTAKE THAT DIDNT MATTER:IGNO REVEALING HIS ROLES ABILITY TO KHON IN DOTA CHAT ON NIGHT 1
BEST THEORY: "The Mafia and SK were able to figure out all of the blue players with the help of zlaker (who requested the janitor cover his tracks) and we are doomed."

thanks everyone for joining the best mafia game ever.

[Ignoritus]

mass murder sure is fun

[TheLordKhon]

mass murder sure is fun

Well played!

[Magna]

That's right bitches, I manipulated all of you. I even killed Jester the first night. I even used Wizard to my advantage for my entire lifetime in the game.

I had quite a few allies, too.

And when I said I knew so much information about everyone, it was because it was true. I made myself seem innocent and everyone came to me and told me their roles because they trusted me.

Anyway, I feel I did well this game, even if I lived for only a night and day. The rest of the Mafia did good, too. They managed to stay alive until the very end.

Good game, everyone. 10/10 would play again.

[Ignoritus]

And when I said I knew so much information about everyone, it was because it was true. I made myself seem innocent and everyone came to me and told me their roles because they trusted me.

This right here ladies and gentlemen is why you need to stop randomly trusting people.

[Bomber57]

Hooray, I got best crazy theory!

[MistakesWereMade]

I always knew ignoritus was that black guy in the hood who robbed you every time you came out of your hosue

also someone fucking message me when the application threads for this shit are out ffs

[Karl Marx]

So if we kill serial killer then he'll kill us instead?

Damn......

[zioy]

Wow, nicely played, Blue Dread, but eventually you died. I personally knew the roles of the yellows by watching the thread intently (I'm trying to get ideas for M5, which I'll join.)

I just want to point out that

You know guys, I think that Igno, Karl, Murph, and Pseudo might be the mafia.

he was nearly right.

You know guys, I think that Igno, Karl, Murph, and Pseudo might be the mafia.

He was 1/2 right, and technically a bit more because the SK isn't town either.

[Julia Pseudo]

WHAT we mafias had this game in the bag! Eh we should've read the rules better I guess, it does say that the serial killer can counter-kill or whatever. Good game Ignoritus, and good game townspeople as well.

[Karl Marx]

WHAT we mafias had this game in the bag! Eh we should've read the rules better I guess, it does say that the serial killer can counter-kill or whatever. Good game Ignoritus, and good game townspeople as well.

damnit you should have consorted igno ffffffff why didnt we think of that

[Magna]

Karl Marx and Pseudo-dino, why the hell did you two visit Ignoritus when you knew he was obviously the serial killer? You two and him are the only ones remaining. If you two did nothing this night, and waited until morning, you could've out-voted Ignoritus and we could've beaten the game.

-_-

[Bomber57]

Karl Marx and Pseudo-dino, why the hell did you two visit Ignoritus when you knew he was obviously the serial killer? You two and him are the only ones remaining. If you two did nothing this night, and waited until morning, you could've out-voted Ignoritus and we could've beaten the game.

-_-

Haw haw haw, you didn't win >::D

[Magna]

Alright so when does M5 start?

Mafia 5: Blame, Bias, and Bandwaggon

Rules:
1. Lynch Blue_Dread from pure bias the first day.
2. Accuse each other without any valid reason, thus killing innocent players accidentally-on purpose.
3. Give your roles away to everyone, and see what happens.

Thats Mafia for ya.

[TLtimelord]

god fucking damnit Blue Dread I will never trust you again XD.

Although if I followed through with my hunches as Vigi, the mafia game would not have gone on for very long. Why? My initial hit list was: Pseudo-Dino, Karl Marx, zlakerboy357, and Joey.

I'd like to say to people this: suspect the QUIETER people first. They may look innocent because they haven't done much, but that's exactly what they want you to hope. My theories in M2 and M4 proved efficient when I suspected Bomber and Khon in M2 and Pseudo and Marx in M4. it's proven highly efficient for me and my personal suspicion list.

In short, this was a lesson to myself to keep my mouth fucking shut and to be more sure of myself. If I were tons smarter this time around, I would have left BG alone, killed off two thirds of the mafia within the first two nights (because Pseudo and Marx were on my top two to kill right from the beginning). And after seeing Igno's suspicious leading skills, announce myself as Vigi and say I'd assassinate him. Once people would see I died, they'd vote Igno.

My dimwitted fantasies aside, shoutouts go to:
Ignoritus: Superb job as Serial Killer. Not only were you a good SK but you made more effective lynches as well. Unlike M2, you intentionally screwed the townspeople.
Blue Dread: Great job instantly acquiring both mine and Wizard's trust and using Wizard for your purpose. The interactions between you and I were mostly you trying to get me to tell everyone you were innocent.
Zlakerboy357: I'm sorry I unintentionally framed you :c
Wizard: I didn't like how you had to depend on people. Try being more independent.

All in all, great game, guys! It was a LITTLE LESS of a total domination for the Mafia than it was in M2.

[zioy]

Alright so when does M5 start?

Mafia 5: Blame, Bias, and Bandwaggon

Rules:
1. Lynch Blue_Dread from pure bias the first day.
2. Accuse each other without any valid reason, thus killing innocent players accidentally-on purpose.
3. Give your roles away to everyone, and see what happens.

Thats Mafia for ya.

Naw, it'll go like this:

1. Godfather is stupid enough to reveal his role the first day over IRC
2. Godfather gets lynched
3. Nobody uses night powers for sake of planning
4. Random user accuses the sheriff of being Mafia
5. Bandwagon lynch on Sheriff
6. Mafia murders Doctor
7. SK murders a townie
8. Bandwagon lynch on SK
9. Mafia murders Townie
10. Bandwagon lynch on a random Townie that claimed
11. Mafia wins

[Ignoritus]

WHAT we mafias had this game in the bag! Eh we should've read the rules better I guess, it does say that the serial killer can counter-kill or whatever.

Actually, you didn't. I was killing you that night anyways. If Karl didn't try to kill me he would have had to kill the remaining Townsperson, which meant I would have been 1:1 with Karl and won anyways since I could nightkill and he couldn't.

[Karl Marx]

Yeah i've never played with a SK before, so that whole concept kinda threw me for a loop there, but you did a fantastic job igno.

And couldn't the townsperson and I have voted to lynch you?

[Ignoritus]

Yeah i've never played with a SK before, so that whole concept kinda threw me for a loop there, but you did a fantastic job igno.

And couldn't the townsperson and I have voted to lynch you?

Well, I suppose you could have chosen to not kill and then done that, but if you did kill you would have had to either target me (suicide), your teammate (lol), or the last green. I figured you lacked the information to realize that not killing was a good tactic.

[Shadow Yoshi]

This game was full of poor strategy. I know a lot of you are new at this, but posts like "I might know something secret, can X special PM me" should raise a red flag.

Mafia requires more analysis, strategy, and technicality/attention to detail than what was shown in this game. *kanyeshrug*