M51: Pick Your Poison {M10A Remastered} - POSTGAME [Player Analysis is here]

[ShadowStarX]

Mafia 51 - Pick Your Poison
Mafia 10A (originally by krazykat) remastered
The game which starts with a choice.

• 15 players
• Cardflip
• 3 sides (Mafia, Town and 3rd party) - 3v11v1
• Semi-mystery

How the game's going to go down:
The game starts off with the players receiving their role PMs, which include a handful of choices to pick. There is a setup phase which'll last for 24 hours. (and won't end sooner under any circumstances due to meta evidence) During this, the mafia and the specials get to pick the roles of their choice, but the mafia only gets to know each other when Night 1 starts. After the setup phase will have ended, the game will go on like a regular game with the role choices staying unknown.

Roles and Role PMs:

You are the leader of the Mafia. You can choose to be: Godfather or Blackmailer
Godfather: Cardflips green upon death and inspection. Your votes are also worth two instead of one and the extra vote can break ties.
Yakuza: Immune to nightkills and ignition.

You are a member of the Mafia. You can choose to be: Consort, Stalker, or Thug
Consort: Can distract a player to roleblock them each night..
Stalker: Can visit a player to check who they visit during the night. Cannot detect the Dissector.
Thug: Can beat up a player each night. If that player dies that night or is lynched the following day, said player will cardflip black. Cannot target the mafia's kill victim.

You are a Town special. You can choose to be:
Sheriff: Can learn the color of a player each night.
Doctor: Can protect a player from being nightkilled each night. Can only self-heal once.
Dissector: Can learn the exact role of a dead player each day. Immune to the stalker's ability.
Vigilante: May kill a player of their choice during the night.

You are a citizen of the Town. You are a Townsperson but potentially a Miller. There could be 0-1 milers and 0-1 millwrights in total.
Townsperson: Can vote during the day in order to lynch
Miller/Millwright: A normal townsperson who flips red upon death or inspection.

You are the Independent criminal. You can choose to be: Serial Killer or Arsonist
Serial Killer: Can kill a player each night. Immune to nightkills.
Arsonist: Can either spill gasoline on a player's house each night or light up all the gased houses on fire. Ignition pierces through protection but not night immunity. Immune to nightkills.

Original game: show

M10A - Pick Your Poison
12 Players - Cardflip

This game would change around the Mystery Game mechanic to better suit creative players. Each player will receive a Role PM as usual, but the Role PM will have a variety of options if the player is chosen as a special role. There is a set number of Mafia, a set number of town, and a set number of third parties, but the player will be able to anonymously choose their role out of a set of possible choices. The game does not start until all players have decided on their role. Likewise, Mafia members will not receive the identities of their allies until they have selected their roles, to prevent plotting before the game starts.

Therefore, here are the possible Role PMs:

You are part of the the Mafia. You can choose to be the Godfather or the Artistic Mafioso.

Godfather - A normal Mafioso who cardflips green.
Artistic Mafioso - A mafioso who can choose to paint players whom the Mafia kill. These paintings will only affect the given player if they are a normal townsperson or a miller.

You are part of the the Mafia. You can choose to be an Eavesdropper, a Propagandist, or a Roleblocker.

Eavesdropper - A mafioso who can choose one person each night. If that person sent the host any messages, they are forwarded to the Eavesdropper.
Propagandist - A mafioso who can tell one person a random secret each night. (Functions the same as the penguin from previous games).
Roleblocker - A mafioso who can choose one person each night. If that person tried to use an ability, it will be blocked.

You are part of the Town. You can choose to be a Sheriff, a Doctor, a Propagandist, an Eavesdropper, or a Doublevoter.

Sheriff - A townsperson who can inspect one person each night to learn their color.
Doctor - A townsperson who can save one person each night to prevent them from dying.
Propagandist - A townsperson who can tell one person a random secret each night. (Functions the same as the penguin from previous games).
Eavesdropper - A townsperson who can choose one person each night. If that person sent the host any messages, they are forwarded to the Eavesdropper.
Doublevoter - A townsperson whose lynch votes count double.

You are part of the Town. You are a Townsperson, who may be a Miller. There may be anywhere from 0-2 Millers.

Townsperson - A normal townsperson with no special abilities.
Miller - A normal townsperson with no special abilities.

Notes: show

• Failed kill attempts against nightkill immunes will not be revealed, but failed killed attempts against players protected by the doctor will
• The Stalker cannot detect the Dissector's actions
• The Mafia only gets to know each other after the Setup phase will have ended

Players: (4/15 alive)
1. Oshi - Survivor
2. Electriking - N1
3. Mechdragon777 - N5
4. GforGoomba - D2
5. TheNewGuy - D1
6. Warlock - N3
7. Pseudo - N2
8. 116taj - Survivor
9. Taycamgame - N4
10. SAStar777 - D5
11. krazykat - N1
12. Eclipsed - N2
13. Thehelmetguy1 - D3
14. Radiance TheDinoKing - D4
15. Cedur - Survivor

Backups:
1. TheDinoKing replaced Radiance at the start of Night 1
2.
3.
4.

Night Summary
Day Summary
Player Analysis

[ElectriKong]

I guess this game was meh cuz N1 death.

[PersonNamedUser]

So i'm allowed to share my opinion on this game since i'm technically unban now right?

[Thehelmetguy1]

I can't believe I will say this, but I am happy that the game rerolled, especially because SAStar got mafia. That game was quite fun. Even if I got unlucky as TP, I am still glad that I was able to enjoy it in the end. It is still a shame since I would have had a chance if I hadn't been caught into that TNG bandwagon. Oh well, better luck to me next time.

[GforGoomba]

I was Miller, as I said the other forum. Still, how can a quirky personality make me sus?

[Cedur]

because mafia members exactly try to stir confusion among the town by pointing fingers at people and accusing them; and most importantly your vote of TNG was way too aggressive to think of you as a townsperson, and you were considered to be aligned with TNG also because you instantly repeated his claims about my alleged role.

You've kept saying useless things, especially these two posts, which only looked as further desparate attempts.

Granted you would have been saved if you didn't have the extra bad luck of being miller, but when being a townsperson it's a must to conduct yourself reasonably and thoughtfully. I've promised to help you and any new player with a guide; I can already send the WIP to you and TNG until it's fully done.

Also hey, you've still won the game.

[Oshi]

Hooray for winning the game and staying alive while doing so for the first time in a while

[GforGoomba]

Hooray for winning the game and staying alive while doing so for the first time in a while

I hope you had fun.

[SAStar777]

I thought that by saying some things I could get Oshi to make it a KITB again. ...I ended up making his head hurt instead.

Also, I'm really starting to wonder how long Helmet usually spends writing up a really good defense while suspected before giving up. This game was, like, the 4th time I saw him say this:

I failed to find an effective way to defend myself.

---

Mafia chat logs (Google Drive folder) if anyone's interested.

[GforGoomba]

I thought that by saying some things I could get Musicality to make it a KITB again. ...I ended up making his head hurt instead.

Also, I'm really starting to wonder how long Helmet usually spends writing up a really good defense while suspected before giving up. This game was, like, the 4th time I saw him say this:

I failed to find an effective way to defend myself.

---

Mafia chat logs (Google Drive folder) if anyone's interested.

Improvise, Helmet

[TheNewGuy]

I wonder what would have happened if there wasn't a reroll

[GforGoomba]

I wonder what would have happened if there wasn't a reroll

I would no have been miller

[Thehelmetguy1]

I thought that by saying some things I could get Musicality to make it a KITB again. ...I ended up making his head hurt instead.

Also, I'm really starting to wonder how long Helmet usually spends writing up a really good defense while suspected before giving up. This game was, like, the 4th time I saw him say this:

I failed to find an effective way to defend myself.

---

Mafia chat logs (Google Drive folder) if anyone's interested.

Improvise, Helmet

Guess what I always do

[Warlock]

So i'm allowed to share my opinion on this game since i'm technically unban now right?

Yes, your gameban is now over.

[GforGoomba]

I thought that by saying some things I could get Musicality to make it a KITB again. ...I ended up making his head hurt instead.

Also, I'm really starting to wonder how long Helmet usually spends writing up a really good defense while suspected before giving up. This game was, like, the 4th time I saw him say this:

---

Mafia chat logs (Google Drive folder) if anyone's interested.

Improvise, Helmet

Guess what I always do

You give up.

[Warlock]

And on another note, well done to the town! That was a good game.

[Thehelmetguy1]

Improvise, Helmet

Guess what I always do

You give up.

No. I improvised in this game. And your defense also failed miserably.

[GforGoomba]

My analysis gon be bad. I know cos I did poorly.

[TDK]

TheNewGuy for townie MVP.

[Archived]

A question to Cedur: Did MECHDRAGON777 ever contact you after I died? I told him that you seemed trustworthy enough and probably could be trusted.