Super Mario Bros. X Forums

Hello folks ! I created a top convey SMEA just so I can see if you like this episode!

 1°: Cavernal Volcano:


 2°: Coming soon.

 If you liked, comment .

I've spiltted the topic in two so I could put the other level in the right forum

Well, it certainly looks very good. What is that white musical note for?

Review - Vulcao 1

I'm not quite sure about the actual name of this level or anything but whatever, vulcao I'm assuming means volcano in another language which is fitting for this.
My initial impressions were..awkward idk. The music was weird, not bad. Hard to tell as of yet if fitting. And the rotodisc was kind of out of place in the beginning area imo.
And then oh boy..moving layers but not moving enemies? Idk. The movement was too jerky, it didn't fit for this style. I'd lower it down slowly, give it a quick pause, and then raise it again.
Heck, moving layers aren't even necessary in that section yet. What I'd do is make smaller platforms and ditch the moving entirely, it was glitching the hammer bros.
Also uh..what's up with this?

it uh..made the rotodisc disappear? Idk if that was intentional or what but like
Idk, just kinda awkward. And then the Sonic-esque switch thing was weird too like wut. Why a pipe? A pipe is not a clear indicator that you're supposed to press it
And then I see another big nono: why would you make spin jumping podobos necessary. Especially right here

WHYWHYWHY
Here's what happened
-Right as I went to spin jump, the fucking fire pirahna shot his load off
-I got hit
-Fell into the lava
-Died
-Killed myself
Either replan your podobo jumping carefully so users don't kill themselves (you got a ghost Luigi reviewing now) or don't do it all.
And then you decided to mix the round ? blocks with the squares, this looks pretty bad imo. the round ones should stay for one purpose if you're going to have the rounds as the "anchor" for the rotodisc

But then came the underground area. I gotta say, this one was really nice looking. The tileset fit nicely but then..a down arrow as a check point? Why why why why why.
The level itself was short though, kind of disappointing if you ask me.

Atmosphere: it didn't quite feel like a volcano, but that's not to say it still wasn't good. 6/10

Gameplay: alot off odd and frustrating design choices that prevented this level from being higher up. 6/10

NPC Placement: not enough npcs really, it felt barren at times 5/10

Graphics: tilsets were nice but some graphics were odd looking. 6/10

Overall Score: 5.75/10 a level that felt alot to be desired. but by no means bad.

uh

a 6.75 isn't an average score

this belongs in pretty good

just sayin'

Kep wrote:uh

a 6.75 isn't an average score

this belongs in pretty good

just sayin'

average is 7+ for me

Luigifan2010 wrote:

Kep wrote:uh

a 6.75 isn't an average score

this belongs in pretty good

just sayin'

average is 7+ for me

It's not "for you". There are level judging rules. http://www.supermariobrosx.org/forums/v ... =32&t=1201

Moved to "Pretty Good" because Luigifan obviously can't read rules

Kep wrote:

Luigifan2010 wrote:

Kep wrote:uh

a 6.75 isn't an average score

this belongs in pretty good

just sayin'

average is 7+ for me

It's not "for you". There are level judging rules. http://www.supermariobrosx.org/forums/v ... =32&t=1201

listen nigga you aint doing the job
this an average level, and i will change the review accordingly if i have to

Luigifan2010 wrote:listen nigga you aint doing the job
this an average level, and i will change the review accordingly if i have to

How is this average if you're giving a level a 6.75? It would, however, be average if you gave it a three, four, or five.

Look, no offense, but you're not fit for the job if you're going to sit there and argue with a former level judge over what board this goes in. I'm not saying you're a bad level judge with your reviewing, it's just that you really need to stop acting like you're always right when it comes to being responsible for the Levels, Projects, and Episodes board. There is a former level judge and an actual level judge correcting you. Please understand this.

Kep wrote:

Luigifan2010 wrote:listen nigga you aint doing the job
this an average level, and i will change the review accordingly if i have to

How is this average if you're giving a level a 6.75? It would, however, be average if you gave it a three, four, or five.

Look, no offense, but you're not fit for the job if you're going to sit there and argue with a former level judge over what board this goes in. I'm not saying you're a bad level judge with your reviewing, it's just that you really need to stop acting like you're always right when it comes to being responsible for the Levels, Projects, and Episodes board. There is a former level judge and an actual level judge correcting you. Please understand this.

i gave it higher than it should've gotten in some places and that can easily offset the scores. i never acted like i was always right in the first place, but this is my level review not yours.

And obviously you were demoted for a reason so idk why you think "former level judge" means anything.

Kep I appreciate that you're trying to help but I'd rather not have you guys start a drama over this.

Luigifan said he would change the review to fit the category he put it in.

And Luigifan please don't insult Kep or you'll start another "the staff is so stuck up" drama.

Thank you.

GLuigiX wrote:And Luigifan please don't insult Kep or you'll start another "the staff is so stuck up" drama.

Thank you.

we ain't even full staff lmao

You get what I mean, no reason to act so disrespectful towards Kep.

He posted a legit complaint.

5/10 and up belongs in the Pretty Good category, and that is final. Luifan, you can change your score accordingly to go in Average if you feel necessary, but for now it's going in the Pretty Good category.

TNTtimelord wrote:5/10 and up belongs in the Pretty Good category, and that is final. Luifan, you can change your score accordingly to go in Average if you feel necessary, but for now it's going in the Pretty Good category.

"Average" - scores of 3/10 to 5/10

and the next post says it rounds down. the review has been changed accordingly if you checked

I think this level is very nice, have a good design and graphics, the npcs was in excellent places, and this level is fun and decent. Has a good gimmick and very well executed! IMO 5.75 is unjust XD

Shinbison-Kof wrote:I think this level is very nice, have a good design and graphics, the npcs was in excellent places, and this level is fun and decent. Has a good gimmick and very well executed! IMO 5.75 is unjust XD

>opinions

Eh I already reviewed this level.

http://www.supermariobrosx.org/forums/v ... =64&t=2782

Reason I copied the topic was because i though he would release more levels here. And to be honest idk how bossedit8 is the op in that topic :/