Put Your Suggestions For 2.0 Here!

[UlticraftMTT]

A few things i would like to see:

X2 Characters (Mega Man, Samus, Bowser, Wario, Rosalina, Solid Snake, Klonoa, Uncle Broadsword, Ultimate Rinka, Zelda) hardcoded into the game, allowing them to be blocked in episodes and other things like that without the need of LunaLua, also the ability to enable or disable certain costumes for a specific episode.

SMB3 Damage system and an option to turn off the Item Box.

Enemies/Bosses i would like to see:

Super Mario Bros. 2:

Pidgit and Magic Carpet
Whale
Tryclyde

Super Mario Bros. 3:

Angry Sun
Pile Driver Micro Goomba
Chain Chomp (I suggest slowing it down to its Super Mario Maker speed as the original SMB3 Chain Chomp is really fast and sometimes unfair)
Cannon
Boss Bass

Super Mario World:

Fishin' Lakitu
Fishin' Boo
Lakitu in a Pipe
Climbing Koopa
Iggy Koopa

Super Mario Maker/Super Mario Maker 2:

Twister
Koopa Troopa Car
Stiletto Goomba

Super Mario Land 2:

Bomubomu/Pig Cannon
Jack-In-The-Box
Bopping Toady

Super Mario 64:

Chuckya
Whomp

Super Mario 3D Land:

Goomba Stack

Super Mario 3D World:

Skipsqueak
Spiny Skipsqueak
Conkdor
Piranha Creeper
Cat Banzai Bill
Hop-Chops
Ant Trooper
Horned Ant Trooper

Zelda Series:

Link's Adventure Goomba

Mega Man Series:

Metall
Telly
Kerog/Croaker


Power-Ups:

Cape Feather
P-Balloon
Superball Flower
Super Mario Maker Clown Car and Fire Clown Car
Buzzy Beetle and Spiny Shellmets


Obstacles:

SMW Disco Ball
SM3DW Blinking Blocks
NSMBW Rolling Hills

[Enjl]

Reminder that builds more recent than Beta 3 (released since this topic's recent bump) make it easy to create custom NPC packs and that literally nothing is stopping anyone from implementing the NPCs and obstacles they wish to see.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LsT7ItnnVzY

Suggestions like "make all characters work on the launcher" make more sense to put here, but then again that particular suggestion has also been on our to-do list for a long time already.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/ ... =568611324

Beyond that, before typing a long list of iconic or less-iconic nintendo enemy names it might be good to take a look through what other people have already made:
SM3DW Blinking Blocks viewtopic.php?f=101&t=24259
Skipsqueak-like viewtopic.php?f=101&t=24438
Stiletto Goomba is literally the already-basegame shoe goomba just with the added impossibility of a useless mount we cannot currently add, so just resprite that.
SMB3 damage system was posted 4 days ago viewtopic.php?f=101&t=24446
Fishin' Boo was posted 3 days ago viewtopic.php?f=101&t=24457
Cannons were posted 1 day ago and already had a previous incarnation in the days of beta 3 viewtopic.php?f=101&t=24469

This thread is pretty much ignored when it comes to actually putting stuff into basegame, but since anyone can add this stuff these days, the void people have been shouting into in this thread has become a bit more filled.

[DrMekar]

Well, okay. My Suggestions for not NPC Stuff:

New Characters (If this could be a thing):
Pyscho Waluigi - Waluigi

New Costumes:

Mario:
SMB2 Mario

Luigi:
SMB2 Luigi
MH2 Ninja Girl (Since this is my Wish List. I'd make all Graphics of course)

Toad:
Diffrent Colour Toads

Mega Man:
MM Series - Mr. X
CaD - Skinner

Wario:
YI - Fat Guy
WMoD Wario

Snake:
Hitman - Agent 47

Uncle Broadsworth:
Just Anythink.

General:
More Vanilla Music/ Or More Custom Music per Section:
While the Music Inis or LunaDLL Method are a thing the ini versionisen't working quite some times and it's
kind of annoying to write/copy a Luna File everytime just to use to Custom Music in one Section for Things
like Boss Fights.

[Enjl]

No, we're not going to bloat the download with junk like costumes and music. I also don't know in what situation you'd ever need to "copy a luna file" in order to play music during a boss fight. You just do Audio.MusicChange(filename) in onEvent when a boss trigger event happens. The music.ini method is reliable too. It reloads music information whenever the smbx process is restarted iirc.
Make waluigi yourself and if it's coded well... you know the drill.

[DrMekar]

No, we're not going to bloat the download with junk like costumes and music. I also don't know in what situation you'd ever need to "copy a luna file" in order to play music during a boss fight. You just do Audio.MusicChange(filename) in onEvent when a boss trigger event happens. The music.ini method is reliable too. It reloads music information whenever the smbx process is restarted iirc.
Make waluigi yourself and if it's coded well... you know the drill.

I understand it with the Costumes, so an offical Subforum for Customes would be Nice. With the Copy I meant for every level you want to use it in. The Music ini method didn't worked for me the last time, thought I'm not
sure if it was because of the Music Length, which was 30 Minutes for the High Quality Version or somethink else. Well, okay. Though I honestly don't know how to make a Character, but Thanks anyway for the offer.

[sammerbro]

junk like costumes

How are costumes junk? I like them!

[Cedur]

junk like costumes

How are costumes junk? I like them!

pretty sure "junk" is used in the context "stuff that takes up disproportionately much space"

[Enjl]

I understand it with the Costumes, so an offical Subforum for Customes would be Nice.

viewforum.php?f=31

[strab]

Since everyone else is posting a list of what they wanna see, I'll post my list

Playable characters:
Donkey Kong (w/ his country moveset)
-Can pick up & throw things which then roll (such as an npc barrel you could add)
-Can roll by pressing alt-run
-Can do the ground slap by pressing down and alt-run/run
-Has the coconut gun (that fires in spurts) replacing the fire flower
Sonic The Hedgehog (w/ genesis moveset)
-Rolls into a ball by running and pressing down (and sliding)
-Can spindash by standing still, pressing down, and pushing jump


Powerups:
Frog Suit


Enemies:
DK Barrel (Arcade)
-Rolls around slowly and hurts you when stepped on/walked into
Icicles that fall down when approached
Donkey Kong (arcade) as a boss
-Remains stationary
-Throws DK Barrels at you


Misc:
More SMB3 level tiles, such as the number tiles (world map)
SMB3 paths (world map)
Being able to select new characters (Wario, Snake, Rosalina) in the launcher and title screen
Being able to block new characters (Wario, Snake, Rosalina) in the map editor (like how you can block mario, luigi, peach, toad, and link)

[Abrahamsitokun2004]

They could add to the mysterious moon (which we are already creating, so wait). You can also add rock, bee and boo mushroom. Please

[Bulby_VR]

I'm not sure if is already implemented, or implementable with lua, but I would like easier access to add frames to player characters, and call frames. Also, (if possible) More limited scope define fields, so you could make 2 player compatible scripts that only apply a define on one player.

[Enjl]

Also, (if possible) More limited scope define fields, so you could make 2 player compatible scripts that only apply a define on one player

This stuff missing is literally why multiplayer with new characters is currently unsupported. Adding this functionality will be the focus of Beta 5's development.

but I would like easier access to add frames to player characters

Basegame playables use playeranim.lua to define custom animation sets. That covers any use case restricted to the vanilla spritesheet layout. If you need a second spritesheet for a playable, you just have to draw the secondary sheet at the right time and set player frame to -50 * player.direction for the duration.

[Teemster2]

Everyone needs to remember the development team may be limited on man power thus they can only do so much.

[cato]

Touhou playable as the characters.

[Taycamgame]

Also, (if possible) More limited scope define fields, so you could make 2 player compatible scripts that only apply a define on one player

This stuff missing is literally why multiplayer with new characters is currently unsupported. Adding this functionality will be the focus of Beta 5's development.

By focus, do you mean that will be the most important feature to get done for beta 5? As I don't think that many people even bother using multiplayer

[ElectriKong]

Also, (if possible) More limited scope define fields, so you could make 2 player compatible scripts that only apply a define on one player

This stuff missing is literally why multiplayer with new characters is currently unsupported. Adding this functionality will be the focus of Beta 5's development.

By focus, do you mean that will be the most important feature to get done for beta 5? As I don't think that many people even bother using multiplayer

More people would bother with multilayer if it functioned properly.

[Hoeloe]

More people would bother with multilayer if it functioned properly.

More, perhaps, but still not many. Multiplayer was an underutilised feature in 1.3 too.

[Cigarettes]

I would like to see some new npc enemys added such as this guy also star power would be nice

[Taycamgame]

BTW can this thread also be used in the way previously mentioned by Enjl? So basically these suggestions don't necessarily need to be implemented into basegame, but people could dip in, have a go at making these suggestions themselves, and then releasing them as a pack? Especially as we have a lot more freedom now when it comes to custom content (such as the expanded range of most things of IDs 751 - 1000), a lot of these suggestions don't seem like they would be needed in basegame.

[Enjl]

I mean no dev ever was influenced by this thread so I thought it was already used that way.