Super Mario Bros. X Forums

Honestly, the graphics request section was one of the most important features of the forum.
The only reason it was closed was that there were impossible or ridiculous requests.
Why can't we just have a rule in place that forbids multiple tilesets/excessive requests in these forums?
Or have a certain post number requirement before you can post requests.

There has only been complaining since it was removed, and after all a forum is supposed to be catering to its users' interests, no?

There were "how to post requests" and rules threads in the old requests forum. Nobody reads them.

LordKofu wrote:Honestly, the graphics request section was one of the most important features of the forum.
The only reason it was closed was that there were impossible or ridiculous requests.
Why can't we just have a rule in place that forbids multiple tilesets/excessive requests in these forums?
Or have a certain post number requirement before you can post requests.

There has only been complaining since it was removed, and after all a forum is supposed to be catering to its users' interests, no?

Even with rules, we'll get people that don't even read them. Also, it was closed for a good reason. It wasn't just one person making really weird graphic requests: the majority of the requests made were either full tilesets or crazy things that often turned out never to be used or only get used for just one level. As to quote Joey: "If you can't make a good level with the thousands of graphics that already exist, you need to work on your level design skills" and I agree with him there. It's not about the custom graphics, it's about how they're used. And also, postcount requirements won't work either because a user can just flood the forum just so they can get the minimum for requesting graphics. Even a user with a lot of posts and thus famous in the community isn't necessarily going to be a good designer.

Linik wrote:

LordKofu wrote:Honestly, the graphics request section was one of the most important features of the forum.
The only reason it was closed was that there were impossible or ridiculous requests.
Why can't we just have a rule in place that forbids multiple tilesets/excessive requests in these forums?
Or have a certain post number requirement before you can post requests.

There has only been complaining since it was removed, and after all a forum is supposed to be catering to its users' interests, no?

Even with rules, we'll get people that don't even read them. Also, it was closed for a good reason. It wasn't just one person making really weird graphic requests: the majority of the requests made were either full tilesets or crazy things that often turned out never to be used or only get used for just one level. As to quote Joey: "If you can't make a good level with the thousands of graphics that already exist, you need to work on your level design skills" and I agree with him there. It's not about the custom graphics, it's about how they're used. And also, postcount requirements won't work either because a user can just flood the forum just so they can get the minimum for requesting graphics. Even a user with a lot of posts and thus famous in the community isn't necessarily going to be a good designer.

Thing is that requests are almost exclusively needed for episodes anyway, for creative gimmicks, bosses, tilesets et cetera.

LordKofu wrote:Thing is that requests are almost exclusively needed for episodes anyway, for creative gimmicks, bosses, tilesets et cetera.

What I would personally suggest, though, is to actually have the requesters make two levels, as for the Levels forum, to demonstrate their level design skills. Like what was said earlier, if you can't make a level with graphics that exist, you need to work on your level design skills. Those with good design skills are allowed access into the Requests forum, and if too many stupid requests are made they are kicked out until something can be decided by the staff. The only downside to that, though, would be having to overhaul the Levels forum again just to accommodate for a forum that totally isn't related.

What do you think of my idea?

A good GFX index would make this completely obsolet-
Oh wait there is one

Waddle Derp wrote:A good GFX index would make this completely obsolet-
Oh wait there is one

You mean this one!

We're not adding back Requests for new graphics at this time, and requesting graphics is definitely not necessary in order to make an episode.

Joey wrote:We're not adding back Requests for new graphics at this time, and requesting graphics is definitely not necessary in order to make an episode.

Well, that does make it impossible to have an actually interesting episode with a unique gimmick because you have to work with general standard stuff everybody can use.

Uh... i mean you can just pm someone, and ask if they would be up for it, or try to make it by yourself and learn how to do them.

LordKofu wrote:

Joey wrote:We're not adding back Requests for new graphics at this time, and requesting graphics is definitely not necessary in order to make an episode.

Well, that does make it impossible to have an actually interesting episode with a unique gimmick because you have to work with general standard stuff everybody can use.

You don't necessarily need custom graphics to have a cool gimmick, but if you do then you can check out the thousands of GFX in the CGFX pack or make something yourself. Ripping and recoloring are not difficult.

LordKofu wrote:

Joey wrote:We're not adding back Requests for new graphics at this time, and requesting graphics is definitely not necessary in order to make an episode.

Well, that does make it impossible to have an actually interesting episode with a unique gimmick because you have to work with general standard stuff everybody can use.

All you need to come up with something unique is being creative and having a large pool of inspiration to choose and combine from.

Joey wrote:

LordKofu wrote:

Joey wrote:We're not adding back Requests for new graphics at this time, and requesting graphics is definitely not necessary in order to make an episode.

Well, that does make it impossible to have an actually interesting episode with a unique gimmick because you have to work with general standard stuff everybody can use.

You don't necessarily need custom graphics to have a cool gimmick, but if you do then you can check out the thousands of GFX in the CGFX pack or make something yourself. Ripping and recoloring are not difficult.

I would like to add to that by saying I even find ripping g graphics fun. Not really that bad...

LordKofu wrote:Well, that does make it impossible to have an actually interesting episode with a unique gimmick because you have to work with general standard stuff everybody can use.

You'd be surprised how far even simple recolors can go.