Super Mario Bros. X Forums

Zeldamaster12: I'd definitely play that.
Pseudo: I went on to edit my thread and accidentally deleted your message that said it was approved; I didn't end up editing anything but could you please rewrite your approval.

Sweet, my game got accepted

8flight wrote:Sweet, my game got accepted

Mine did too. And then I deleted the part of the post that says it was accepted, by accident. Stupid me.

Not actual Reviews yet but little things that I realised:

Jacob: Jester seems kinda op with the NK immunity. Maybe take that out, because the only way he doesn't win is if Town wins without lynching him and that seems way too easy to prevent on his side. Maybe only immunity for N1 or smth.

RudeGuy07: I'm assuming each person only gets the power for that night and on the next one, the special chooses another (or maybe the same) target, right?

Spinda he does not have night kill immunity i just did not word it right.
I meant to say that if he gets killed at night he loses the game. I shod re word that

PixelPest wrote:Pseudo: I went on to edit my thread and accidentally deleted your message that said it was approved; I didn't end up editing anything but could you please rewrite your approval.

No problem, done.

Pseudo-dino wrote:

PixelPest wrote:Pseudo: I went on to edit my thread and accidentally deleted your message that said it was approved; I didn't end up editing anything but could you please rewrite your approval.

No problem, done.

Also, is their any progress on this?

http://www.supermariobrosx.org/forums/v ... 20#p194035

@Spinda: Yes, that's right.

OK, I've reviewed all of the games that have been submitted now.

Retweeked game based on earlier reviews.

Pseudo-dino wrote:The Role Roulette mechanic would be really confusing and not all that fun IMO. I really can't approve a game that has something like that; I feel like it's directly against the spirit of Mafia game mechanics (everybody collects evidence using their powers and interrogation to find out who people are. I can give you a better review if you remove or change that mechanic (if it were consolidated to a single player power that could change someone's role I'd be good with that, for example.

I changed it so it happens right before night 1, and it is restricted to a character power to only three uses.

Is host sign ups this long? And if the poll will make it longer thats just annoying.
At least make the poll a day or 2 not a week, we need activity not inactivity

Jacob wrote:Is host sign ups this long? And if the poll will make it longer thats just annoying.
At least make the poll a day or 2 not a week, we need activity not inactivity

It typically takes two weeks if I remember correctly. The time is taken by Spinda and Pseudo-Dino reviewing and re-reviewing the games.

Then we need more gms then, as 2 gms is not enough gms, we can see that already. And with this surge of activity more gms is something that would be recommended

Hey look a last minute game!

I'm not willing to host this so Pseudo can if it wins.

Folsom Prison Blues
-18 players
-Daily message

Mafia Aligned
Bartender - Same as godfather but blue
Paralyzer - Stops a town lynch once.
Driver - Switches the actions done on two players.
Strongman - survives 1 nightkill

Town Aligned:
Sheriff
Doctor
Vigilante
Jailer - Can jail a player
Bulletproof - Survives 1 nightkill
Townsperson
Townsperson
Townsperson
Townsperson
Townsperson
Townsperson
Miller
Millwright

Neutral
Serial Killer

Notes:

Pseudo-dino wrote:I would change either the Bartender or the Disguiser; having only two confirmed reds in a four-player Mafia seems a little OP.
It's otherwise good though.
OK it's good now.

Spinda wrote:Approved.

Sorry for the inconvenience y'all I'll review them later but it's 2 am atm so I gotta get some sleep first.

TNT: Having a 3rd Party be able to kill somebody after their death is a really bad idea because at that point they've lost anyway and got nothing to gain from killing anyone specifically, making it essentially a pure meta kill. Especially since the SK himself doesn't gain anything from killing someone.
Also, what if the Maf Jailor jails the Town Jailor and the Town Jailor jails the Cop? Will the Cop be jailed or will the Town Jailor be jailed? What if both jail each other? Will both br jailed or will neither be?
What if the Driver switches himself and Player A, and the Jailor jails Player A? Will the Driver or Player A be jailed?
Also, will the Disguiser keep his color for the following day?

Jacob wrote:Then we need more gms then, as 2 gms is not enough gms, we can see that already. And with this surge of activity more gms is something that would be recommended

Can you like stop being so impatient? Pseudo and Spinda do a fine job. Just because they don't get the games reviewed right away doesn't mean they're inadequate at their job.

Spinda wrote:Sorry for the inconvenience y'all I'll review them later but it's 2 am atm so I gotta get some sleep first.

TNT: Having a 3rd Party be able to kill somebody after their death is a really bad idea because at that point they've lost anyway and got nothing to gain from killing anyone specifically, making it essentially a pure meta kill. Especially since the SK himself doesn't gain anything from killing someone.
Also, what if the Maf Jailor jails the Town Jailor and the Town Jailor jails the Cop? Will the Cop be jailed or will the Town Jailor be jailed? What if both jail each other? Will both br jailed or will neither be?
What if the Driver switches himself and Player A, and the Jailor jails Player A? Will the Driver or Player A be jailed?
Also, will the Disguiser keep his color for the following day?

All of those answered or fixed. The Disguiser and Driver loopholes you tried to find aren't there. The Driver DOES get jailed and the Disguiser keeps the color for a single phase. before reverting back to red.

I am not saying they are inadequate, (i respect them very much) i am saying that this is something that can not be done by just two people with the recent surge. The surge itself will make it more stress inducing and they have lives outside of here. What i am saying is to have more people like help out so like when they are gone so they have to deal with the struggle of doing this.

I reviewed your game, TNT.