Page 5 of 12
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:19 pm
by underFlo
Wind wrote:Not only is this a shameless *ahem* rip-off of our TAOK RPG, but you also stole one of our assets (the valtteri face in screenshot 3)
and guess what
we're not going to give you permission to use our graphics (yes i finally get to be the party crasher)
so apparently every RPG revolving around the community in some way is a TAOK RPG ripoff now? ok
And no the Valtteri face also isn't a reason to call it a ripoff.
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:36 pm
by Wind
Gee, didn't expect people to take me this seriously.
Like, come on. I never said it was the valtteri face that made it a rip-off.
SnifitGuy wrote:Exactly. First off, Wind, you don't have to let him use graphics, but you can't copyright the concept because TAoK just so happens to base around the community too. It's like me saying "You can't breath in the air because I breathed out CO2 and a tree converted it back to O2". No, you can't do that.
Second off, you're TAoK RPG isn't currently being updated, because nobody has updated the damn thing. This, on the other hand, is being updated and discussed constantly, so don't say that this is a ripoff when TAoK RPG isn't even being discussed anymore.
First off, SnifitGuy, I never copyrighted anything. Why did you use the word "copyright" when I did not, in fact, copyright anything? The reason is the same as to why I used the word "rip-off".
Also, Martin just happened to started working on the game again. Maps have been added and a lot of gfx have been done.
And decreasing my reputation won't help that one bit, buster.
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:43 pm
by The Wizard of Off
Wind wrote:Gee, didn't expect people to take me this seriously.
Like, come on. I never said it was the valtteri face that made it a rip-off.
Actually you did say that valterri's face made it a ripoff
Wind wrote:Not only is this a shameless *ahem* rip-off of our TAOK RPG, but you also stole one of our assets (the valtteri face in screenshot 3)
and guess what
we're not going to give you permission to use our graphics (yes i finally get to be the party crasher)
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:46 pm
by zlaker
SnifitGuy wrote:Second off, you're TAoK RPG isn't currently being updated, because nobody has updated the damn thing. This, on the other hand, is being updated and discussed constantly, so don't say that this is a ripoff when TAoK RPG isn't even being discussed anymore.
Just because he hasn't updated it doesn't it mean it's still not in development.
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:47 pm
by Wind
The Wizard of Off wrote:Wind wrote:Gee, didn't expect people to take me this seriously.
Like, come on. I never said it was the valtteri face that made it a rip-off.
Actually you did say that valterri's face made it a ripoff
Wind wrote:Not only is this a shameless *ahem* rip-off of our TAOK RPG, but you also stole one of our assets (the valtteri face in screenshot 3)
and guess what
we're not going to give you permission to use our graphics (yes i finally get to be the party crasher)
Read it again. "But you also..."
I never implied it made the whole game a rip-off. God dammit, I should have used the word "clone" instead. I just have this magical power to start shitstorms when i dont want to
also snifitguy bring it on
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:50 pm
by The Wizard of Off
Wind wrote:The Wizard of Off wrote:Wind wrote:Gee, didn't expect people to take me this seriously.
Like, come on. I never said it was the valtteri face that made it a rip-off.
Actually you did say that valterri's face made it a ripoff
Wind wrote:Not only is this a shameless *ahem* rip-off of our TAOK RPG, but you also stole one of our assets (the valtteri face in screenshot 3)
and guess what
we're not going to give you permission to use our graphics (yes i finally get to be the party crasher)
Read it again. "But you also..."
I never implied it made the whole game a rip-off. God dammit, I should have used the word "clone" instead. I just have this magical power to start shitstorms when i dont want to
also snifitguy bring it on
clone is basically a synonym for rip off
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:54 pm
by Wind
The Wizard of Off wrote:clone is basically a synonym for rip off
Basically? Hmm???
What I would mean by clone is "a game with exact same ideas".
Rip off is more of a negative term (which i regret using) but still, rip off would mean stealing the spotlight and idea of a game.
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:57 pm
by Valentine
THIS GAME IS NOT ABOUT THE SAME THING. READ THE NAME "The SMBX Forums Tale" DOES IT SAY TAOK ANYWHERE? NO!
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:58 pm
by Wind
By the way, this is becoming a real smbx forums tale
Also Little Boo, the screenshots scream TAOK. Or maybe it's just me?
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 1:58 pm
by Bomber57
Little Boo wrote:THIS GAME IS NOT ABOUT THE SAME THING. READ THE NAME "The SMBX Forums Tale" DOES IT SAY TAOK ANYWHERE? NO!
At this point is more about using the Valtteri graphic without permission (I assume you didn't get permission to use it) and less about the fact that it happens to be a RPG with forum members in it.
Considering you said you would remove it and look for an alternative, this argument has no reason to continue.
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 2:05 pm
by zlaker
SnifitGuy wrote:Wind wrote:By the way, this is becoming a real smbx forums tale
Also Little Boo, the screenshots scream TAOK. Or maybe it's just me?
1/3 screenshots have 1 AoK graphic in them. Otherwise, there is nothing else that has a similarity to TAoK RPG.
TAOK is the main concept in the TAOK RPG, however in this RPG it's about the SMBX forums. So since 1/3 of the screens are TAOK isn't that kinda copying?
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 2:11 pm
by qig
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 2:14 pm
by Wind
dmca take down claim incoming
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 2:49 pm
by Valentine
I got you guys a new screenshot
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 3:49 pm
by Sevennights
Nice mafia reference there.
Still looks to innocent to be mafia.
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2014 9:23 pm
by DatDude
Little Boo wrote:I got you guys a new screenshot
You should give him the Deal with It Glasses, and a Top Hat. And some other Mafia sh!t.
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Mon Dec 08, 2014 7:54 am
by Knux
Wind wrote:Not only is this a shameless *ahem* rip-off of our TAOK RPG, but you also stole one of our assets (the valtteri face in screenshot 3)
and guess what
we're not going to give you permission to use our graphics (yes i finally get to be the party crasher)
Might I add that you never asked for permission to use my graphics either?
It's pretty hypocritical for you to have a go at someone else for using characters when you didn't even ask me if I was fine with you using
my works for your own RPG. And if you want to know, I am fine and have no problem with characters/locations from TAOK being used in fan works, but remember that I made them and therefor it's not up to you if someone else uses my material or not.
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Mon Dec 08, 2014 2:12 pm
by qig
Knux wrote:Wind wrote:Not only is this a shameless *ahem* rip-off of our TAOK RPG, but you also stole one of our assets (the valtteri face in screenshot 3)
and guess what
we're not going to give you permission to use our graphics (yes i finally get to be the party crasher)
Might I add that you never asked for permission to use my graphics either?
It's pretty hypocritical for you to have a go at someone else for using characters when you didn't even ask me if I was fine with you using
my works for your own RPG. And if you want to know, I am fine and have no problem with characters/locations from TAOK being used in fan works, but remember that I made them and therefor it's not up to you if someone else uses my material or not.
damn u tell them knux
))
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2014 12:57 pm
by Knux
Little Boo can still use TAOK graphics if he wants to.
Re: The SMBX Forums Tale (RPG) (WIP)
Posted: Tue Dec 09, 2014 1:09 pm
by Danny
Knux wrote:Wind wrote:Not only is this a shameless *ahem* rip-off of our TAOK RPG, but you also stole one of our assets (the valtteri face in screenshot 3)
and guess what
we're not going to give you permission to use our graphics (yes i finally get to be the party crasher)
Might I add that you never asked for permission to use my graphics either?
It's pretty hypocritical for you to have a go at someone else for using characters when you didn't even ask me if I was fine with you using
my works for your own RPG. And if you want to know, I am fine and have no problem with characters/locations from TAOK being used in fan works, but remember that I made them and therefor it's not up to you if someone else uses my material or not.
Yet still, Panda made the graphics to begin with, so regardless if it is TAOK, she should still have a say in whether other people can use the graphics she worked on herself, it doesn't matter if you made the characters or not.
