Page 5 of 7
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:12 pm
by zioy
Bomber57 wrote:KoolKat wrote:Bomber57 wrote:Alright guys, I am gonna stop you there.
Joey has picked three games that he sees would be the best candidates for a balanced, fair, and most importantly fun game of Mafia.
He has stated several times that, if you wanted criticism on your Mafia game or perhaps even consideration for it being added to the poll you simply PM him.
Now, quit complaining about your game not making it into the poll, as there is probably good reason for it.
Do you think mine will be approved once he gets back on though?
I cannot say that.
Anyway, at this point, if I see any more whining I will lock the topic.
Honestly, (I know you can't) but a board warning would be more appropriate. Locking the topic would result in a riot, most likely. I wouldn't participate in that though.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:24 pm
by TLtimelord
Jacob9300Shadow wrote:Still sir... the percentage of all of those role that have percent like things like the surgeon or the sneaky Mafioso... you should get rid of those roles or change them in a way... i don't see the other games use percentage, or do you really want your game to be noticed... WELL I NOTICED KID!!!
I did like his sneaky mafioso role and how they risk their role being revealed by finding out other roles. My issue with his game is he has the mafia, the vigi, and two seperate serial killers. That's a whopping max of 4 deaths per night, coupled with lynching during the day. I'd tone the deaths down a bit by removing a serial killer.
As for Koolkat, your judge role is overpowered, as well as an easy target. Their lynch ending the vote on someone means no one else can get a say in that lynch from any point afterwards, plus another instant lynch on someone else (this could technically count as a day kill. I also think the artistic mafioso is rather pointless, except for killing a fake miller. The role will be the equivalent to being nullified if they kill someone with the same color that the artistic mafia chose.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:25 pm
by zioy
TNTtimelord wrote:Jacob9300Shadow wrote:Still sir... the percentage of all of those role that have percent like things like the surgeon or the sneaky Mafioso... you should get rid of those roles or change them in a way... i don't see the other games use percentage, or do you really want your game to be noticed... WELL I NOTICED KID!!!
I did like his sneaky mafioso role and how they risk their role being revealed by finding out other roles. My issue with his game is he has the mafia, the vigi, and two seperate serial killers. That's a whopping max of 4 deaths per night, coupled with lynching during the day. I'd tone the deaths down a bit by removing a serial killer.
As for Koolkat, your judge role is overpowered, as well as an easy target. Their lynch ending the vote on someone means no one else can get a say in that lynch from any point afterwards, plus another instant lynch on someone else (this could technically count as a day kill. I also think the artistic mafioso is rather pointless, except for killing a fake miller. The role will be the equivalent to being nullified if they kill someone with the same color that the artistic mafia chose.
I removed the judge
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:26 pm
by Sevennights
If there are riots... i will kill everyone... mainly for the blood over my body... RIOTS SHOULD BE A MECHANIC FPR THE Mafia game and sorry for yelling and my weird obsession with the blood though... ;_;
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:27 pm
by Sevennights
Wait... how abput if there were 50 people in the game... and role could be give mpre then once... but a only 4 deaths a day.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:28 pm
by Valentine
if you want riots join #mafiariots.
Seriously though, i find games that are not actually on the poll very good
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:33 pm
by Shadow Yoshi
Please make better posts, Jacob9300Shadow.
I picked the three games that had the least problems. I wanted you guys to PM me so that I didn't have to write everything out in one huge post. I'm a bit short on time at the moment.
There's no need for everyone to get so angry about it.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:35 pm
by zioy
Joey wrote:Please make better posts, Jacob9300Shadow.
I picked the three games that had the least problems. I wanted you guys to PM me so that I didn't have to write everything out in one huge post. I'm a bit short on time at the moment.
There's no need for everyone to get so angry about it.
I'm not angry
But I updated my game, is it acceptable now?
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:35 pm
by Shadow Yoshi
I'm not adding anything more to the poll.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:37 pm
by zioy
Why not? It seems like if the game was bad at first but is now way better it can't be approved.
Are you going to change the poll eventually, just not tonight?
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:37 pm
by TLtimelord
KoolKat wrote:TNTtimelord wrote:Jacob9300Shadow wrote:Still sir... the percentage of all of those role that have percent like things like the surgeon or the sneaky Mafioso... you should get rid of those roles or change them in a way... i don't see the other games use percentage, or do you really want your game to be noticed... WELL I NOTICED KID!!!
I did like his sneaky mafioso role and how they risk their role being revealed by finding out other roles. My issue with his game is he has the mafia, the vigi, and two seperate serial killers. That's a whopping max of 4 deaths per night, coupled with lynching during the day. I'd tone the deaths down a bit by removing a serial killer.
As for Koolkat, your judge role is overpowered, as well as an easy target. Their lynch ending the vote on someone means no one else can get a say in that lynch from any point afterwards, plus another instant lynch on someone else (this could technically count as a day kill. I also think the artistic mafioso is rather pointless, except for killing a fake miller. The role will be the equivalent to being nullified if they kill someone with the same color that the artistic mafia chose.
I removed the judge
I didn't say you should remove the judge. But anyways, I think the Doublevoter would be a nice replacement.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:39 pm
by Sevennights
Well as others said before Joey has chosen 3 of the games that could be the most fun and functional.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:39 pm
by zioy
TNTtimelord wrote:I didn't say you should remove the judge. But anyways, I think the Doublevoter would be a nice replacement.
I removed the judge because Bomber told me to as advice.
Anyway, if Joey isn't going to change the poll, I'm voting for you
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:41 pm
by Magna
Joey wrote:I'm not adding anything more to the poll.
This is the end. :c
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:44 pm
by zioy
Well, I voted TNT. As long as I can participate it's good. However, be prepared for
M6 - Colorful Catastrophe
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:45 pm
by Sevennights
That is a movie reference and i Jacob, agree with Joey's decision to keep it fair.. and i like it fair for all.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 10:50 pm
by FallingSnow
Edit of previous posting:
Mafiafia
20 Players
Cardflip
Role usage is optional.
Team Mafia
Godfather - Cardflips green.
Janitor - May clean a player during the night up to two times throughout the game. If target player is killed, their color becomes unknown.
Consort - May distract a player each night and prevent them from using a role ability.
Spy - May spy on a player during each night phase and learn if they visited someone.
Team Town
Sheriff - May inspect one player each night to learn their color.
Deputy - Assumes the Sheriff's role and color if he is killed. Has contact with the Sheriff.
Doctor - May save one player from death each night. May only self-heal once.
Nurse - Assumes the Doctor's role and color if he is killed. Has contact with the Doctor. May never self-heal upon becoming the doctor.
Bodyguard - May protect one player from death, inspection, distraction, or being spied on each night. If the protected player is to be killed, the Bodyguard will die instead.
Escort - May distract a player each night and prevent them from using a role ability. Does not prevent mafia killings.
Townie
Townie
Townie
Townie
Townie
Townie
Townie
Townie
Red Miller - Cardflips red. Does not know they are the Red Miller.
Blue Miller - Cardflips blue. Does not know they are the Blue Miller.
Removed two mafia members for townies, renamed the Miller to the Red Miller, and renamed the Mason to the Blue Miller.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2014 12:16 am
by HeroOfRhyme
You guys do know that in some board softwares, once you start a poll, you cannot change anything about the poll? Perhaps thats the same here. Also, I would stop nagging Joey, because it'll only make things worse.
Oh yeah, and...TNT4prez.
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2014 12:51 am
by zioy
SonGohanssj2 wrote:You guys do know that in some board softwares, once you start a poll, you cannot change anything about the poll?
Not with phpBB. You can add stuff/delete in it
Re: M5: Host Signups
Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2014 10:15 am
by RudeGuy
KoolKat wrote:SonGohanssj2 wrote:You guys do know that in some board softwares, once you start a poll, you cannot change anything about the poll?
Not with phpBB. You can add stuff/delete in it
Yeah, but after all the votes are deleted.