M28 - Bomb Squad TOWN VICTORY

Zeldamaster12 · Postby **Zeldamaster12** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 7:10 pm

Sorry, TheDinoKing, you waited too long. The phase ended at 7:00.

BADA BOOM!

Nobody died!

It is now NIGHT 2! NIGHT 2 will end on March 19, 2016 at 7:00 PM EST!

Waddle · Postby **Waddle** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 7:13 pm

TheDinoKing42, I'd like to know why exactly you voted Nato; it's making you look rather suspicious.

Nato · Postby **Nato** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 7:36 pm

I claim doctor and no one counter claims.

How on earth does that make me both suspicious and a candidate to vote?

TLtimelord · Postby **TLtimelord** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 7:53 pm

Waddle Derp wrote:TheDinoKing42, I'd like to know why exactly you voted Nato; it's making you look rather suspicious.

No, it just makes him look fucking stupid and imcompetent at playing mafia.

Dude, get your shit together, no one counterclaimed, Nato is completely clean in my book.

Zeldamaster12 · Postby **Zeldamaster12** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 8:18 pm

TNT, chill.

Sevennights · Postby **Sevennights** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 8:47 pm

Nato wrote:I claim doctor and no one counter claims.

How on earth does that make me both suspicious and a candidate to vote?

Inactive doc
Maybe who knows
Hell you could be baiting and making things worse for the doc
(I rather have different wording but no one will let me run my passionate words)
Really im going through all the scenarios and you play p well
So i am gonna believe you are not doc

Nato · Postby **Nato** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 8:52 pm

And you could have said that excuse on anybody else who claimed.

Being obstinate like that isn't good.

Nato · Postby **Nato** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 9:02 pm

Also another query has come up.

I'm thinking of healing myself, but I'm also thinking about healing another person. PM me a reason why I should heal you. That is, if you trust me enough to do just that.

Kyo Saito · Postby **Kyo Saito** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 9:15 pm

At least we did not lose Nato.

Yes, I agree though, TheDinoKing432 should not have voted to lynch Nato, as he could have been the doctor, especially if nobody counterclaimed.
I guess it is a good thing we didn't lynch anybody off, but eventually we should find somebody that is truly suspicious.

Jacob wrote:
Nato wrote:I claim doctor and no one counter claims.

How on earth does that make me both suspicious and a candidate to vote?
Inactive doc
Maybe who knows
Hell you could be baiting and making things worse for the doc
(I rather have different wording but no one will let me run my passionate words)
Really im going through all the scenarios and you play p well
So i am gonna believe you are not doc

But can I ask how that make sense? The chances of the doctor being inactive are not very high. And Nato probably would not bait the doctor, as the sheriff can easily inspect him tonight to confirm his color.
Also, I do not think the actions of a player in a past game would reflect how they would act in this one, just saying.

Sevennights · Postby **Sevennights** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 9:20 pm

You are really playing it cool right now, like you really dont care about dying
Thats not a way to as doc by many people I've seen play doc (AND NONE OF THEM CLAIMED TILL THE COP DIED)
And you wsnt people to pm why they should not be killed?
Sigh

Zeldamaster12 · Postby **Zeldamaster12** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 9:27 pm

message to all players:

y'all should use #smbxgames more

Kyo Saito · Postby **Kyo Saito** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 9:32 pm

Jacob wrote:You are really playing it cool right now, like you really dont care about dying

But the thing is, if he needs to tonight, he can always heal himself instead of someone else.

Nato · Postby **Nato** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 9:41 pm

Kyo Saito wrote:
Jacob wrote:You are really playing it cool right now, like you really dont care about dying
But the thing is, if he needs to tonight, he can always heal himself instead of someone else.

True, but I'll do WIFOM logic for right now to confuse the mafia since that's the only thing I can do.

Kyo Saito · Postby **Kyo Saito** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 10:10 pm

Now that seems a little silly.

MistakesWereMade · Postby **MistakesWereMade** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 10:15 pm

thing is, your bait might've been too over the top, so assuming it's correct, mafia can just target someone else.

Sevennights · Postby **Sevennights** » Fri Mar 18, 2016 10:30 pm

I Admit it is bait is just so bad
Really bad
(I have different, more choice words)
Like its makes you seem so bad just admitting its bait out in the open
That just makes things so much worse ok
Like you could be mafia for all.we know
Seriously like, who would claim doc day one without cop, cop being dead, and who claim their claim is bait WHO WOULD DO THIS, WHO!?
So this in turn really makes me suspicious of you, really suspicious

Nato · Postby **Nato** » Sat Mar 19, 2016 12:24 am

I think standing aside letting things happen is a crazier approach. That and a less then 5% chance of healing someone properly.

Like seriously, what were you planning later on in the game if someone didn't claim something. It's the doc, who can protect themselves on a whim.

Kyo Saito wrote:Now that seems a little silly.

Alright then. I'll just heal myself and be done with that. No baiting. I state my intentions clearly. The mafia have no need to target me, and in fact I urge them too. That way I'll just heal myself. So if the mafia target me, I'll live. That's right, I'll live.

...You see now what I'm going for. If I die now then it will all be for naught. Keep in mind that I'm also looking ahead to where I want to keep the mafia hesitant to kill me because the question they'll always ask is "Do I have a self-heal?".

I'm a doc. I claimed. Live with it. Being obstinate to not accept this fact just hurts town @Jacob.

Kyo Saito · Postby **Kyo Saito** » Sat Mar 19, 2016 12:36 am

Jacob wrote:I Admit it is bait is just so bad
Really bad

It isn't all that bad, but only if it's used in a more strategic manner.

Jacob wrote:(I have different, more choice words)

What would those choice words be?

Jacob wrote:Like its makes you seem so bad just admitting its bait out in the open
That just makes things so much worse ok

I admit saying it's bait out in the open is a really foolish thing to do, but even if he was the doctor, at least he isn't getting a kill on him, which means he has the chance to protect someone else. I guess it depends on the situation.

Jacob wrote:Like you could be mafia for all.we know

But we don't know that for sure. Unless someone counterclaims as being the doctor, there is no reason why we shouldn't believe Nato for the time being. It is best to know who the doctor is then instantly call them a mafia member, I think that's a big jump to conclusions and a poor tactic.

Jacob wrote:Seriously like, who would claim doc day one without cop, cop being dead, and who claim their claim is bait WHO WOULD DO THIS, WHO!?

I am having a hard time understanding this one. Does it matter when the person claims their role? It's better that we know they did now than maybe four days later having them claim their role when everyone important is already dead. Regardless if Nato really is the doctor or not, I'm not sure why people are seeing him as suspicious. I would be suspicious if they started asking for PMs exclusively, but seeing as he has only made that part optional, it should be fine.

Nato wrote:
Kyo Saito wrote:Now that seems a little silly.
Alright then. I'll just heal myself and be done with that. No baiting. I state my intentions clearly. The mafia have no need to target me, and in fact I urge them too. That way I'll just heal myself. So if the mafia target me, I'll live. That's right, I'll live.

...You see now what I'm going for. If I die now then it will all be for naught.

But here is the problem. If you tell the Mafia to target you and you do have the ability to heal yourself tonight, then they would have a stronger motive to not kill you and kill somebody else. We as the town are supposed to be working against the mafia, not giving them ideas on what to do next.

Kyo Saito · Postby **Kyo Saito** » Sat Mar 19, 2016 12:37 am

Nato wrote:...You see now what I'm going for. If I die now then it will all be for naught. Keep in mind that I'm also looking ahead to where I want to keep the mafia hesitant to kill me because the question they'll always ask is "Do I have a self-heal?".

I'm a doc. I claimed. Live with it. Being obstinate to not accept this fact just hurts town @Jacob.

You are not allowed to edit your posts in Mafia, just to let you know.

Sevennights · Postby **Sevennights** » Sat Mar 19, 2016 12:59 am

Kyo Saito wrote:
Nato wrote:...You see now what I'm going for. If I die now then it will all be for naught. Keep in mind that I'm also looking ahead to where I want to keep the mafia hesitant to kill me because the question they'll always ask is "Do I have a self-heal?".

I'm a doc. I claimed. Live with it. Being obstinate to not accept this fact just hurts town @Jacob.
You are not allowed to edit your posts in Mafia, just to let you know.

where the hell did you come from one punch man with lenny face from left field speaking like you are a common player

Where did he edit his posts, i do not see this
Or at least i most likely overlooked it

Nato you say you arr baiting then you say you dont thrn you do then you dont
This is either the best mind fuck, or you are panicking
And if i dont accept it i hurt town? I hurt town by being myself and try to give out my suspicions, which work 30/70, not very high, good, now let me say you are doc, and i stop being what you said i am, (to lazy dont want to type) what next what do you do, what can you do? What is the major plan? Bring the alliance of justice together (actually that is a good name, keep it)
And save town? Seems so easy to do, but seems like it will never work, at all, if you die or if you are lying, i am neutral with you ok, i really dont believe it if you are doc since docs never claim day one, its extremely unsafe, extremely unsafe, so that is really what makes me not believe you and inactive freaking people you know, they might be doc, hell the doc may have died! (Idk if paintings woek the kill night or.not, i really forgot and did not check)
So that is what makes me not believe you, at the very moment at the very least