Page 27 of 42
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 7:55 pm
by XerX
Layla wrote:Finished judging.
I want to let you all know this is probably my favorite contest ever when it comes to design. I was still a pretty damn strict judge though, so if anyone has an issue with my reviews or even scores, please PM me so we can get things figured out. I'm always open to changing a score, but not once results are out, sorry.
I'm a bit confused. You are open to changing the score, but not when the results are out.
How will we know our scores then?
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 8:01 pm
by TLtimelord
XerX wrote:Layla wrote:Finished judging.
I want to let you all know this is probably my favorite contest ever when it comes to design. I was still a pretty damn strict judge though, so if anyone has an issue with my reviews or even scores, please PM me so we can get things figured out. I'm always open to changing a score, but not once results are out, sorry.
I'm a bit confused. You are open to changing the score, but not when the results are out.
How will we know our scores then?
Let me better explain that.
I won't change scores but I will better explain why I gave your level that score.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Sun Dec 21, 2014 11:04 pm
by MECHDRAGON777
SuperMario7 wrote:Layla wrote:Finished judging.
I want to let you all know this is probably my favorite contest ever when it comes to design. I was still a pretty damn strict judge though, so if anyone has an issue with my reviews or even scores, please PM me so we can get things figured out. I'm always open to changing a score, but not once results are out, sorry.
Cool! Do you have like a list of guesses for whose level is whose or something like that? I always find those interesting. =P
When wi you released your guesses
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 12:29 am
by Willhart
CaptainSyrup wrote:No Valtteri said he did not sent the joke levels to the judges. Why should they be judged anyway. We all know they either won't be in tob or land in tier 1 and show how bad this community is.
I'd say this is only a good thing considering it speeds up the judging process. Do kaizo levels count as joke levels too?
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 3:21 am
by Waddle
Willhart wrote:CaptainSyrup wrote:No Valtteri said he did not sent the joke levels to the judges. Why should they be judged anyway. We all know they either won't be in tob or land in tier 1 and show how bad this community is.
I'd say this is only a good thing considering it speeds up the judging process. Do kaizo levels count as joke levels too?
Yeah, they do. Rereading the main post, it says that extreme skills (kaizo levels, impossible puzzles/mazes) should not be asked from judges (nor players) so They'll probably end up in the joke section.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 9:48 am
by Sux
Would be interesting a list of the guess of the judges on the authors of some levels. Long time I no see do it...
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 10:24 am
by Kyo
Sux wrote:Would be interesting a list of the guess of the judges on the authors of some levels. Long time I no see do it...
This. It would have to happen after the judging phase ends and before the revealing phase begins.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 10:28 am
by ssumday
Kyo wrote:Sux wrote:Would be interesting a list of the guess of the judges on the authors of some levels. Long time I no see do it...
This. It would have to happen after the judging phase ends and before the revealing phase begins.
I agree, although the judges hardly known my levels.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 2:49 pm
by Getlucky12341
My name isn't on the list of contestants.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 2:50 pm
by TLtimelord
FireLink wrote:Kyo wrote:Sux wrote:Would be interesting a list of the guess of the judges on the authors of some levels. Long time I no see do it...
This. It would have to happen after the judging phase ends and before the revealing phase begins.
I agree, although the judges hardly known my levels.
I personally thought it was pretty obvious which level was yours.
Of course, I could always be wrong
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 3:01 pm
by JupiHornet
Shouldn't you replace the name TNTimelord with Layla?
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 8:13 pm
by sezixor
I agree about doing the list of level predictions. I'm also curious to see who the judges think made what level. Besides, I think it's been a few contests since anyone's done that.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 9:10 pm
by JupiHornet
sezixor wrote:I agree about doing the list of level predictions. I'm also curious to see who the judges think made what level. Besides, I think it's been a few contests since anyone's done that.
Didn't zlaker do it last contest?
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Mon Dec 22, 2014 9:25 pm
by sezixor
I meant an actual list of predictions that a judge posts before the release of the results, not in the actual reviews.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2014 5:51 am
by zlaker
Getlucky12341 wrote:My name isn't on the list of contestants.
You got disqualified, sorry :/
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2014 6:42 am
by Waddle
zlakergirl357 wrote:Getlucky12341 wrote:My name isn't on the list of contestants.
You got disqualified, sorry :/
maybe you shud tell him WHY he got disqualified?
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2014 6:56 am
by ssumday
Waddle Derp wrote:zlakergirl357 wrote:Getlucky12341 wrote:My name isn't on the list of contestants.
You got disqualified, sorry :/
maybe you shud tell him WHY he got disqualified?
Did you read the rules? He probably broke some.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2014 6:59 am
by zlaker
Waddle Derp wrote:zlakergirl357 wrote:Getlucky12341 wrote:My name isn't on the list of contestants.
You got disqualified, sorry :/
maybe you shud tell him WHY he got disqualified?
He got disqualified for having a mp3 file that was longer than 6 minutes. That was at least what Valtteri said on the IRC.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2014 7:56 am
by Mable
FireLink wrote:Waddle Derp wrote:
maybe you shud tell him WHY he got disqualified?
Did you read the rules? You probably broke some.
Let's be honest... How many people maybe read the rules of this contest. IMO 4%.
Re: Winter Contest: The Judging has Begun!
Posted: Tue Dec 23, 2014 8:26 am
by Willhart
zlakergirl357 wrote:He got disqualified for having a mp3 file that was longer than 6 minutes. That was at least what Valtteri said on the IRC.
According to the first post, that should only decrease the score by one.