Super Mario Bros. X Forums

castlewars wrote:I have a feeling this will be the CC10 judge lineup:

Chad
bossedit8
GLuigiX
Raster
Quill
(Valtteri)

But you don't really need to be liked by Valtteri to be a judge - it's just a matter of how good your reviews are and if you're fit to review a load of levels for a community contest without any hassles getting in the way.

Chad, Quill, and GluigiX are the only confirmations. Raster, to my knowledge, is still banned.

Why would he want to judge in the first place?

Hmmm. Well I'm reviewing a level sent by some to work on me and Waddle Derp's episode. I guess I could be a judge assuming the Winter contest is during my Christmas break :/

castlewars wrote:But you don't really need to be liked by Valtteri to be a judge - it's just a matter of how good your reviews are and if you're fit to review a load of levels for a community contest without any hassles getting in the way.

Then why am I never chosen? You just don't see a lot from me because I mainly do project beta and anime reviews, but Valtteri should actually be aware that I am qualified enough for the job (sorry if I sound arrogant or anything). It's been two years since I was a CC judge and I've been trying to get a position again ever since.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but ever since CC7 Valtteri has only picked the judges personally :/

zlakerboy357 wrote:Correct me if I'm wrong, but ever since CC7 Valtteri has only picked the judges personally :/

That sucks
Idk if he even likes me or not, but level judging sounds like fun :/

GLuigiX wrote:Also I think the judges for the next contest are already kinda set? (idk I just know that I'll be one of them and Luigifan probably too hyak)

I never said Luigifan2010 would be a judge. :P

Turtwig wrote:Idk
I know I'd wanna be a judge :P
How do you become one anyway

I personally pick people who I deem good level designers and capable of the job.

Kyo wrote:There are two conditions. The first one is you'll need to be a decent reviewer. The second is, you'll have to be liked by Valtteri.

This kind of comments certainly won't make me want to make you a judge more. The reason we were reluctant to make you a judge again was because you caused controversy last time. You have to understand that we want to hire judges who are least likely to give bad reviews, and we typically don't rehire people who didn't do very good. But to be fair, it's been two years and you must have changed a lot, so I'll consider you for the next contest. There's a bunch of people I'm thinking I'll be picking 5 from for the next contest.

Emral wrote:That'd be nice! I always wanted to be a judge in one of these!

Are you angry because your reviews were generally frowned upon last time?

castlewars wrote:I have a feeling this will be the CC10 judge lineup:

Chad
bossedit8
GLuigiX
Raster
Quill
(Valtteri)

But you don't really need to be liked by Valtteri to be a judge - it's just a matter of how good your reviews are and if you're fit to review a load of levels for a community contest without any hassles getting in the way.

That's an odd lineup. Raster is permanently banned. :/ But you are very correct in the last sentence.

At least that was cleared up...

Valtteri wrote:This kind of comments certainly won't make me want to make you a judge more. The reason we were reluctant to make you a judge again was because you caused controversy last time. You have to understand that we want to hire judges who are least likely to give bad reviews, and we typically don't rehire people who didn't do very good. But to be fair, it's been two years and you must have changed a lot, so I'll consider you for the next contest. There's a bunch of people I'll be picking 5 from for the next contest.

The second condition was a joke btw. Your choices aren't bad, but if I'm honest, I'm still not digging the idea of relying on a single person that decides the entire judge lineup. I do trust you, though letting the community decide was a better idea imo.

Well roughly, 4 days left and I can't wait to see the results...

Its like waiting for Christmas and opening the biggest presents first on a "white Christmas" day then having a a glass of eggnog and chocolate peanut butter cookies
(sorry if i made you hungry )

dragonfan96 wrote:Well roughly, 4 days left and I can't wait to see the results...

Its like waiting for Christmas and opening the biggest presents first on a "white Christmas" day then having a a glass of eggnog and chocolate peanut butter cookies
(sorry if i made you hungry )

I think you mean 6 days because the deadline is Oct. 13.

dragonfan96 wrote:Well roughly, 4 days left and I can't wait to see the results...

Its like waiting for Christmas and opening the biggest presents first on a "white Christmas" day then having a a glass of eggnog and chocolate peanut butter cookies
(sorry if i made you hungry )

Don't wanna ruin your day, but you have to wait other 2 weeks for the results.

RarePairGaming wrote:

dragonfan96 wrote:Well roughly, 4 days left and I can't wait to see the results...

Its like waiting for Christmas and opening the biggest presents first on a "white Christmas" day then having a a glass of eggnog and chocolate peanut butter cookies
(sorry if i made you hungry )

I think you mean 6 days because the deadline is Oct. 13.

If you couldn't see/hear it but that "thud" sound was my hand connecting to my forehead.....*facepalm*

dragonfan96 wrote:Its like waiting for Christmas and opening the biggest presents first on a "white Christmas" day then having a a glass of eggnog and chocolate peanut butter cookies
(sorry if i made you hungry )

I will never forgive you.

Meh. I don't even like peanut butter XD

Valtteri wrote:

Emral wrote:That'd be nice! I always wanted to be a judge in one of these!

Are you angry because your reviews were generally frowned upon last time?

No, actually. In retrospect, I was a bit too harsh with the scores I gave. But watching everyone rage at that, leaving the community behind mid-contest and getting notified I won against the three levels I gave a full score and considered better than mine, was a lot of fun. Still today just the irony about it puts a smile on my face. However, I still can't decide which of the other three levels I would've placed in first, they're all so epic *-*

Also, that post you're quoting in yours is pure irony for anyone who missed it.

Also, surprise! I got better stuff to do than designing a level for this. Dropping out.

Emral's last sentence like

castlewars wrote: Chad
bossedit8
GLuigiX
Raster
Quill
(Valtteri)

Idt bossedit will be a judge bc a lot of people weren't okay with the scores he gave actually.
Also Quill not sure he doesn't have a lot of time now since he started his college life. Hes rarely online now.

CaptainSyrup wrote:Also Quill not sure he doesn't have a lot of time now since he started his college life. Hes rarely online now.

Sorry to disappoint you but

Damn Quills Meme Picture in Facebook though.

Ok then he might be a judge.

Hmm. I'll probably apply next contest.