FutureNyanCat2014 wrote:SMW enemies do not have shading at all
Kep wrote:Super Mario World-esque enemies aren't intended to include shading
Both of you are wrong.
SMW enemies do have shading, but it's less developed than the non-comic-style shading found in the other mario games. In case of enemies like the Ninji, this no-shading-style is present, but most of the enemies have one standard and dark colour, sometimes even a light colour on top of that.
Now, your shy-guy uses the light and standard colour while it should use all 3 or the 2 darker ones. Yours looks too bright and doesn't fit in the invironment. Besides, I'm not sure if I'm right, but I don't think the greys on the mask and shoes are on the palette.
And yes, sometimes they do swap the palette to include more shading, but what's wrong about doing that. It serves it's purpose.