Page 3 of 15
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 9:22 am
by Cedur
I'm trustworthy, and if you don't believe me, Santa may inspect me next night to find out that I'm green ("nice") or the miller ("neither / nor"). We should pull this off so we at least don't lose a blue in the case of an all-player kitb.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 10:00 am
by Valentine
Yeah but I doubt anyone's gonna immediately just gonna go and tell you their role.
The way you acted in saying that everyone should just till you their role during the day phase makes it kind of strange.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 10:11 am
by Cedur
Blues should claim so we have a blue alliance AND we can put a vote on someone who's not a blue, to protect the blues from a random lynch, like I said. We don't have any other leads. Timezones could be a hindrance for me maybe, though. I hope to get at least two blue claims.
Btw Sanct, if you continue being skeptical, I'll maybe also consider putting a vote on you.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 11:05 am
by Julia Pseudo
Supershroom wrote:If the Caroler uses his ability, only alive players will be mentioned, right?
Yes
Supershroom wrote:When Santa gives out an item at night, can it be used immediately?
Items distributed by Santa (or the Associate) are received at the beginning of the following day phase.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 11:17 am
by Julia Pseudo
The Anti-Person hasn't reads role PM, so TNTtimelord has now been subbed in to replace him. Welcome aboard!
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 11:26 am
by TLtimelord
Funny thing about the epicmafia equivalent of the caroler, if only a few players remain and there's one mafia, they had the potential to appear twice on the caroler report.
But anyway here I am a townsperson if that helps.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 11:38 am
by Valentine
Supershroom wrote:Btw Sanct, if you continue being skeptical, I'll maybe also consider putting a vote on you.
Do you even know how mafia works
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 11:44 am
by Cedur
I know in the meanwhile, and I've checked the role list to see if starting a blue alliance would produce any exploits (like a godfather asking the blues to claim since he cardflips green, but there is no such role here). If there's any problem I overlooked, pls tell.
And yeah, you could be a blue yourself who's afraid of revealing their role. And the last thing I want is a blue dying from a kitb.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 3:19 pm
by Doesntpostverymuch
I'm with sanct, Why Should we trust you?
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 3:27 pm
by Ness-Wednesday
Supershroom wrote:And the last thing I want is a blue dying from a kitb.
Why would we trust you?
Secondly, no one here would bother spoiling their role anyway.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 3:28 pm
by ShadowStarX
I don't know why should we trust Supershroom either.
However, I wouldn't make speculations yet, since it's only day 1 and I don't want to mess up like last time on Day 3.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 3:30 pm
by TLtimelord
I suspect Danny and ZM for the fact they find Spinda's playing style as annoying as I do. If they had a killing role, they'd kill Spinda.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 3:30 pm
by TLtimelord
Hey hey hey! You vegged out get out of here person!
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 3:31 pm
by ShadowStarX
Oh whoops, sorry never mind...
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 3:43 pm
by MECHDRAGON777
TNTtimelord wrote:Hey hey hey! You vegged out get out of here person!
What does "Vegged" mean anyway? Either way, I do not want a 12 way Knife-in-the-Box. My suspicion is on Superstition for the time being.
Supershroom wrote:A couple of questions first after looking through the role list:
Since the Associate knows their comrades, they'll just simply give a gun to another Mafia member early in the game for an additional nightkill? It would be more interesting if he had to give the gun to a townsperson.
If the Caroler uses his ability, only alive players will be mentioned, right?
When Santa gives out an item at night, can it be used immediately?
Anyway, Spinda probably died because it's a common fate of experienced players to die early.
I'm a normal townie, so all blues can claim to me to start a blue alliance (I don't see any loopholes for that), so we could at least vote someone who's not blue.
Supershroom wrote:A couple of questions first after looking through the role list:
Since the Associate knows their comrades, they'll just simply give a gun to another Mafia member early in the game for an additional nightkill? It would be more interesting if he had to give the gun to a townsperson.
If the Caroler uses his ability, only alive players will be mentioned, right?
When Santa gives out an item at night, can it be used immediately?
Anyway, Spinda probably died because it's a common fate of experienced players to die early.
I'm a normal townie, so all blues can claim to me to start a blue alliance (I don't see any loopholes for that), so we could at least vote someone who's not blue.
Supershroom wrote:A couple of questions first after looking through the role list:
Since the Associate knows their comrades, they'll just simply give a gun to another Mafia member early in the game for an additional nightkill? It would be more interesting if he had to give the gun to a townsperson.
If the Caroler uses his ability, only alive players will be mentioned, right?
When Santa gives out an item at night, can it be used immediately?
Anyway, Spinda probably died because it's a common fate of experienced players to die early.
I'm a normal townie, so all blues can claim to me to start a blue alliance (I don't see any loopholes for that), so we could at least vote someone who's not blue.
Supershroom wrote:A couple of questions first after looking through the role list:
Since the Associate knows their comrades, they'll just simply give a gun to another Mafia member early in the game for an additional nightkill? It would be more interesting if he had to give the gun to a townsperson.
If the Caroler uses his ability, only alive players will be mentioned, right?
When Santa gives out an item at night, can it be used immediately?
Anyway, Spinda probably died because it's a common fate of experienced players to die early.
I'm a normal townie, so all blues can claim to me to start a blue alliance (I don't see any loopholes for that), so we could at least vote someone who's not blue.
About the Associate, if they can give guns to their allies, I think the role would be over-powered. Why would she or he be allowed to do that? (It would be nice to know if we could exspect that, but still.)
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 3:50 pm
by Witchking666
Ness-Wednesday wrote:Supershroom wrote:And the last thing I want is a blue dying from a kitb.
Why would we trust you?
Secondly, no one here would bother spoiling their role anyway.
Except he is probably pretending to be a special townie whilst in fact he is a mafioso.
Sanct wrote:witchking666 wrote:Ness-Wednesday wrote:while we're setting up a plan
But townies don't make plans.
But you don't know how to play mafia
As a matter of fact, I do. Even though I never played a game of mafia on any forums whatsoever I played the werewolf game (basically mafia in real life with cards and such showing your role) countless times.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 3:53 pm
by Doesntpostverymuch
i also played real-life mafia, but was never the mafia.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 4:02 pm
by Cedur
For the people who haven't figured it out, what I wanted is having blues claiming in private to me, not in public, so I could bring them together and we could possibly find mafiosos trying to infiltrate the ally through counterclaims. And I also wanted to use this in order to avoid a blue being lynched, but now it's getting late for me.
If this is not safe for you, alternatively you can also have a weaker blue like the Penguin claiming publicly and the other blues claiming to him. Though I'm not sure if any blues really want to reveal themselves.
Just let Santa prove that I'm trustworthy and we're good to go.
Also Mechdragon, "vegged" = kicked for inactivity (being subbed or, if no substitute available, insta-killed). And lol you quoted me four times
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 4:13 pm
by Valentine
The only reason I didn't immediately lynch you was because we know that all the blues were alive and just killing you here could easily be a waste.
Re: M33: Christmas is a Few Months Early... Day 1
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2016 4:14 pm
by MECHDRAGON777
Supershroom wrote:For the people who haven't figured it out, what I wanted is having blues claiming in private to me, not in public, so I could bring them together and we could possibly find mafiosos trying to infiltrate the ally through counterclaims. And I also wanted to use this in order to avoid a blue being lynched, but now it's getting late for me.
If this is not safe for you, alternatively you can also have a weaker blue like the Penguin claiming publicly and the other blues claiming to him. Though I'm not sure if any blues really want to reveal themselves.
Just let Santa prove that I'm trustworthy and we're good to go.
Also Mechdragon, "vegged" = kicked for inactivity (being subbed or, if no substitute available, insta-killed). And lol you quoted me four times
On my phone, I hit quote only once. I can not edit it to remove it though.