Super Mario Bros. X Forums

8flight wrote:

qig wrote:

8flight wrote: Unless you are a red then what evidence do you have? I said 2 reds claimed to Me. Unless I get a counter claim, there is no reason not to trust them. Also keep in mind bomber claimed miller around a whole 1-2 days after I claimed miller. Also he has not answered my question yet.

The burden of proof is on you.

So why would Bomber not counterclaim miller immediately after NATO explained why doing not would severely damage the town. He knew I was going to get the role list. If you knew your Cc was about to get the role list why would you not claim? Also why did you read my pm ignore and for a bit and then send me that youre the ISP?

Bomber57 wrote:

Nato wrote:

Bomber57 wrote:Because, the problem with claiming miller right away is that if people dispute it it literally derails the discussion and has one of two outcomes: You either get lynched right away and the Town is down a man, or the Mafia can sew doubts about you for the rest of the game until you are lynched or until they just decide to kill you so less people can vote against them.

There is literally no reason to claim miller straight away that is good. This is a rare circumstance because I counterclaimed Miller to show that 8flight isn't who you think he is.

No, there was.

8flight claimed miller. The sheriff would not be confused if he investigated the 8flight and found he was mafia. The mafia then can't just say "I'm the miller" when they get asked the question. 8flight took himself and put him on the stand for the sake of the town, to which he played his role well.

No matter what, he forced the other miller to act. There was no argument, the other miller had to claim in order so that 8flight didn't get the roles and overall didn't confuse the town. There was no other thing you could have done, 8flight forced any other miller to claim unconditionally.

Which no one did for a time.


And as proven by 8flight- if you claim right away, you won't get immediately lynched. The mafia can't sew doubts about you.

And now were in the situation.



Anymore, cause if you want to get lynched tomorrow then vote for 8flight. Though know thats exactly whats going to happen if you don't vote for Khon.

Cause if you don't vote for Khon and your innocent, you won't be proven and you'll be lynched since your doing exactly what a mafia member would do if they didn't want the town to find out their identity.

I don't understand what you are saying here. The Mafia can and WILL sew doubts about you because getting you killed means one less person to vote against you.

The only reason Mafia never tried to lynch 8flight was because he was gaining ground, an fast. He has a ton of people who seem to believe him and, if they tried to vote against him, people would think they are mafia, just like you guys seem to think Khon and I are now just because we are against blindly giving our roles away to someone who is suspicious.

Bomber57 wrote:Well, to be frank I idle everywhere. Always.

I repeat, your not working in the towns favor by lynching 8flight.

Nato wrote:

ragont wrote:

Nato wrote: Do I need to explain to you too man?

Let's go. Let's do this. Talk to me.

explain what

...To vote for Khon.

Your voting 8flight.

Or do you admit your voting 8flight and don't want to switch because your mafia. Is that right?

qig wrote:

I repeat, your not working in the towns favor by lynching 8flight.

We're getting rid of the person who is idiotically giving away 'roles' to people willy-nilly.

qig wrote:

8flight wrote:

qig wrote:
The burden of proof is on you.

So why would Bomber not counterclaim miller immediately after NATO explained why doing not would severely damage the town. He knew I was going to get the role list. If you knew your Cc was about to get the role list why would you not claim? Also why did you read my pm ignore and for a bit and then send me that youre the ISP?

why arey ou just asking me a bunch of irrelevant questions lol

ragont wrote: do you get off on sounding like a retard
im voting 8flgith because not only is he detrimental to our progress, but he's also throwing his vote out just to save his own ass without any evidence

Nato wrote:

ragont wrote: do you get off on sounding like a retard
im voting 8flgith because not only is he detrimental to our progress, but he's also throwing his vote out just to save his own ass without any evidence

I'm getting called a retard by a guy who can't spell flight.

Truly unique, these forums.

Nato wrote: 1. 8flight, if anything, got a discussion started where their would be none day 1.

8flight wrote:

qig wrote:

8flight wrote: So why would Bomber not counterclaim miller immediately after NATO explained why doing not would severely damage the town. He knew I was going to get the role list. If you knew your Cc was about to get the role list why would you not claim? Also why did you read my pm ignore and for a bit and then send me that youre the ISP?

why arey ou just asking me a bunch of irrelevant questions lol

These questions are relevant. How are they irrelevant? Answer them or are you avoiding something?

Bomber57 wrote:Why do you guys seem to thing voting for Khon is the only thing that proves my innocence? What makes your claim of "killing khon is harmless" valid?

ragont wrote:

Nato wrote: 1. 8flight, if anything, got a discussion started where their would be none day 1.

And now everyone's confused to all hell, thanks to him.
Good on him then, I guess?

Nato wrote:

Bomber57 wrote:Why do you guys seem to thing voting for Khon is the only thing that proves my innocence? What makes your claim of "killing khon is harmless" valid?

There are two miller claimants. You and 8flight.

8flight claimed that Khon said to him he is the ISP. Khon refused this.

If Khon is the ISP, we know 8flight is town miller. Therefor you must be guilty miller.
If Khon is town, we know 8flight is the mafia miller. Therefor you must be town miller.