Super Mario Bros. X Forums

i dont think theres any reason for him to lie about being silenced

on a side note did joey die? like he hasn't posted in a bit but i don't see it on the main page

Fyrus wrote:on a side note did joey die? like he hasn't posted in a bit but i don't see it on the main page

i mean if you don't see it on the main page it's because he didn't die

Well, that sucks. I assume he was the weapon master?

At least he has an heir, though. Probably.

I can vouch for the logs posted earlier.

it could be possible ragont was the inspector though

either way that fucked us up

Also, good to hear that Khon is a non-mafia. Though I'm not sure what leads that leaves us with (but no leads is arguably better than false leads).

Fyrus wrote:it could be possible ragont was the inspector though

either way that fucked us up

He was the original Weapons Master. That means the inspector is still alive.

Wait, I just realized that the upgraded roles are also pink. Scratch that last response. ;P

Fyrus wrote:and how do we know he left an heir? i'm a bit confused here

If Ragont didn't pick a heir, someone random is picked as the heir.

oh! i didn't know that actually

also oops i deleted my response prematurely f

So...Khon is at the top of my suspicion list right now.

At first he was able to, by chance (?), select Marina as someone who was in the Mafia. And then the next day he was silenced, except it's pretty easily to fake a silencing when half of the players haven't really been active anyway. Sounds like he's trying a bit too hard to win the town's trust!

we're in the awkward position where we have basically nothing but raw suspicions to go on, yet we can't really afford to lose anyone else

alright no offense but you like literally begged for all of the blues to come to you and pm you and were screaming that the curist needed to help you even though you didn't die in either of the last two nights, and now we've lost two specials in two nights and that's a bit more suspicious than a random guess at an afk player who was also mafia

you're not even FULLY confirmed, it's just an assumption that we've made based on previous things that YOU have said, and the "easily faked silence" thing does in fact turn itself around on your original argument

so no, i don't think we need to be lynching someone because they claimed to be silenced

....you know

i didn't even consider that but this is fucking shady

i've assumed joey has been confirmed this entire game, and so has basically everyone else. he outright claimed vigi, got in contact with some of the blues, and suddenly blues start dying every night. on top of that, he's been a self-confessed blue for two seperate nights without the curist and still hasn't been killed despite being one of the biggest threads to the mafia.

i'm not ready to throw my hat in this ring quite yet as like I said we all did kind of consider him "confirmed" and he could potentially be the best chance we have of cleaning up this mess, but yeah

it would be pretty masterful if the person more or less leading this shitshow was mafia all along

my biggest holdup on that is why the "real" vigi hasn't counterclaimed if that's the case

it was mostly a counterargument and a mild hunch, and i'm not saying we should lynch him

and that's precisely why

Because I'm the real vigi and if anyone had counterclaimed back then they would've hopefully been inspected. In retrospect, I probably could've just vigi'd them!

As for the silencing argument, I realize how it could turn back on me: however, I've been active this whole game specifically except for the one phase for which I was silenced.

...we do on the other hand have an afk player it seems...

if we lynch him and he's vigi, it'll tell us an awful lot

on the other hand if joey's legit and we lynched a random we're back at square one

so do we risk exposing a mafioso at the expense of a lynch and a night, or do we do something else? personally since he's afk i'm inclined to go for this, but i'll remind everyone it's stupidly risky

i also realize i put myself on the chopping block as well if he's not the vigi, but we don't have a lot of leads so i'll take the risk

HenryRichard