M37: Peak Oil, 200 Years Too Soon - Town Wins

[Julia Pseudo]

NIGHT 3 has ended!

glitch4 got up bright and early after staying out late the previous night, stalking his target. He was determined to stop the gangsters at all costs, and as the craziest gun in the west, he believed that all the responsibility fell to him to do so. Excited after his exploits last night, he paraded into the town square carrying the body of his victim King of Eterity.

"I got one of 'em!" he shouted to the townspeople, stopping at every house.
But just as he threw the body to the ground, it exploded, destroying all the evidence.
King of Eterity has died! The corpse was unidentifiable.

The shockwave from the explosion sent glitch4 flying into the general store, the impact breaking his neck.
glitch4 has died!
The office of Doc Fesstival issued an autopsy, identifying him as vigilante gunman Crazy Carl Williams!

It is now DAY 3! Day 3 will end around 9:00 PM Eastern Standard Time, April 1, or earlier if there are enough votes for an insta.

As you may have noticed, we staff have changed our usernames to Yoshi-themed names for an upcoming event. Since this is only temporary, please vote to lynch players, if applicable, under their usual names for the purposes of posterity.

In case anyone's unclear
Orange Yoshi = Zeldamaster12
Pink Yoshi = Waddle Derp

[Sevennights]

im just gonna leave it here and let you all react

[Thehelmetguy1]

Sneaky bastards

[Megar]

judging by the miller issue, it's safe to assume the mafia tried to hide his being the real miller from us via bomb
which means Shroom is mafia

[Zeldamaster12]

Shocking, glitch4, the one most notorious for signing up every game and doing hardly anything, was the Vigi, who didn't claim to Megar.

Anyways, Supershroom, you're done friendo.

[Ness-Wednesday]

Well then supershroom I think you should come clear on the excuse why we lost one (or likely two) townspeople and one of them being a blue despite the plan was to gather them in case this happens?

[Thehelmetguy1]

Supershroom, you may want to defend yourself.

[MacDuckBeat]

Great god Supershroom

[Cedur]

Well then supershroom I think you should come clear on the excuse why we lost one (or likely two) townspeople and one of them being a blue despite the plan was to gather them in case this happens?

Come on, this was quite predictable to happen? The mafia would obviously paint KoE since he was nearly safe to get vigi'd, it's the same thing as in M28 when TheDinoKing died, and again the former ("he was mafia and smokescreen painted him to hide that he was red") is true (especially they don't want us to know if we maybe hit the jackpot aka Johnny Peterson).

As for glitch4, that's also not hard to explain. Since there were still blue claims missing, the Mafia went for someone who has not been very active and therefore been likely to miss out claiming even when being prompted. Mega never told me any identities of potential blues and he should confirm this.

I'm gonna think out who's best to lynch instead, but at this point you're just about to pull off another M36 ShadowStar and all the tangible evidence still cuts down to what happened before Night 3, when KoE made a really awkward vote and never cared to explain it. If he hadn't been scum, he should have been fairly able to explain his motive.

[Cedur]

As for now I'm lynching Zeldamaster12 for directly jumping on the bandwagon (six minutes after Mega's vote), while I'm the one being manipulated myself. For the same reason I also suspect RSuper (since she's been mostly inactive otherwise). Mega, thg1 and Ness-Wednesday are confirmed or pretty much confirmed townies, the rest is difficult to judge.

[Valentine]

Honestly supershroom's logic has been pretty sound and helpful for the town thus far. But I don't really find zeldamaster suspicious either so I'm not going to vote.

They're both pretty good and honestly I feel like they're both town.

[Cedur]

ZM hasn't really acted suspicious thus far but now he jumped on my throat and looking at the list of players alive and confirmed, I guess I figured out that both of them are Mafia.

[Sevennights]

Well then supershroom I think you should come clear on the excuse why we lost one (or likely two) townspeople and one of them being a blue despite the plan was to gather them in case this happens?

Come on, this was quite predictable to happen? The mafia would obviously paint KoE since he was nearly safe to get vigi'd, it's the same thing as in M28 when TheDinoKing died, and again the former ("he was mafia and smokescreen painted him to hide that he was red") is true (especially they don't want us to know if we maybe hit the jackpot aka Johnny Peterson).

i like just said this in discord the other day

give the fact i also said the that i feel the mafia started the bandwagon
i know its wrong to go off of gut feelings but i have to say im lynching Zeldamaster12

[Ness-Wednesday]

Well then supershroom I think you should come clear on the excuse why we lost one (or likely two) townspeople and one of them being a blue despite the plan was to gather them in case this happens?

Come on, this was quite predictable to happen? The mafia would obviously paint KoE since he was nearly safe to get vigi'd, it's the same thing as in M28 when TheDinoKing died, and again the former ("he was mafia and smokescreen painted him to hide that he was red") is true (especially they don't want us to know if we maybe hit the jackpot aka Johnny Peterson).

i like just said this in discord the other day

give the fact i also said the that i feel the mafia started the bandwagon
i know its wrong to go off of gut feelings but i have to say im lynching Zeldamaster12

Point taken, I feared more of another townsperson being killed than a blue, but with the acts and minor speaking.
Zeldamaster12 is clearly, hiding something.
With these suspicious feeling overnight, I find it quite possible as he killed both of them overnight.

[Zeldamaster12]

You all are missing the fact that King of Eterity and Shroom both claimed Miller, so it is either King of Eterity or Shroom that is Mafia. Shroom would be gutsy enough to claim Miller to fool everybody, but unfortunately we're smarter than that. Placing a bomb on King of Eterity won't fool anyone either.

[Cedur]

Well, my claim is obviously that KoE was mafia and they anticipated the vigilante's kill.

[Sevennights]

mafia could have killed their own so we could lynch a town

[Cedur]

That's straightly impossible. The vigilante killed KoE and the Mafia killed the vigilante, that's without question.

[TDK]

You guys are a bit too trigger happy.

Both Supershroom and King of Eterity claimed Miller, so either one of them is the Mafia. Since these two are the most likely to be Mafia, it is mostly likely that the vigilante killed one of them and one of them was smokescreen. But which one?

Let's look at 4 cases.

Case #1: The Mafia dies and is painted.
The Miller would seem to be to be scum, and would be most likely be lynched.
This would result in the death of a Mafia and a Townie.

Case #2: The Mafia dies, but the Miller is painted.
Miller is confirmed innocent, and doesn't get lynched.
This result in the death of only the Mafia.

Case #3: The Miller dies, but the Mafia is painted.
Mafia is confirmed scum, and is lynched.
This results in the death of a Mafia and Townie.

Case #4: The Miller dies, and is painted.
The Mafia would seem to be to be scum, and would be most likely be lynched.
This would result in the death of a Mafia and a Townie.

Case #1,#3,#4 all will result in a Mafia and Townie dying. Only case #2 is when the Miller doesn't die.
To prevent Case #2 from happening (and therefore preventing the death of the Miller), the Mafia would want to paint the Mafia.

Overall, it's most likely for the Mafia (instead of the Miller) to be painted.

[Zeldamaster12]

Well, my claim is obviously that KoE was mafia and they anticipated the vigilante's kill.

It's the same odds if KoE was the miller and the Mafia painted him to make everyone clueless on his real identity.