M5: Playing with Fire (REROLL)

[qig]

Guys, I really don't think PaperPlayer is Mafia.

We should be lynching Nien.

1) He was extremely quick to change his vote yesterday from Fallingsnow to myself, as we all know, Fallingsnow was likely the Arsonist,
2) He sent messages to various people on steam asking them to not lynch vote Fallingsnow.
3) Instead of simply ignoring the PM asking for peoples roles or giving a reasonable responses, he told PaperPlayer to go "fuck himself"

Lastly, I've been contacted by the Sheriff who has told me that Nien has in fact, cardflipped red.

[MistakesWereMade]

Unfortunately for Nientiendo, he doesn't know how to play this game. When I told him of my suspicions he was mafia he panicked and role-claimed Miller. Unless the Sheriff inspected him and then decided it would be a brilliant idea to contact him, he has absolutely no way of knowing that. Since our Sheriff this game didn't feed their role to the Mafia and has managed to share information without revealing themselves I feel it's a safe assumption to make that they wouldn't do that. He only claimed Miller in an attempt to explain-away a Red cardflip if I were the Sheriff and had inspected him.

PaperPlayer is weird, but we have nothing proving he's Mafia and not just playing terribly. Nien can't say the same.
Lynch Nien.

Excuse me? Do i have the face of a liar? I was just defending myself so my goodie-oodie-boodie-frienderino didn't vote to lynch me like an asshole, now, if we suspect anyone, it should be paperplayer, he's acting extremely paranoid, while i haven't been giving too many fucks this game.

[Valentine]

I have suspisions that PaperPlayerX is the mafia, the chances are pretty high. If he turns up red, he IS 99.9% the mafia, because i know who the miller almost certainly is and it's not him, it is not nien either.

[Valentine]

Guys, I really don't think PaperPlayer is Mafia.

We should be lynching Nien.

1) He was extremely quick to change his vote yesterday from Fallingsnow to myself, as we all know, Fallingsnow was likely the Arsonist,
2) He sent messages to various people on steam asking them to not lynch vote Fallingsnow.
3) Instead of simply ignoring the PM asking for peoples roles or giving a reasonable responses, he told PaperPlayer to go "fuck himself"

Lastly, I've been contacted by the Sheriff who has told me that Nien has in fact, cardflipped red.

I agree with you i change my vote to Nien

[Ignoritus]

Unfortunately for Nientiendo, he doesn't know how to play this game. When I told him of my suspicions he was mafia he panicked and role-claimed Miller. Unless the Sheriff inspected him and then decided it would be a brilliant idea to contact him, he has absolutely no way of knowing that. Since our Sheriff this game didn't feed their role to the Mafia and has managed to share information without revealing themselves I feel it's a safe assumption to make that they wouldn't do that. He only claimed Miller in an attempt to explain-away a Red cardflip if I were the Sheriff and had inspected him.

PaperPlayer is weird, but we have nothing proving he's Mafia and not just playing terribly. Nien can't say the same.
Lynch Nien.

Excuse me? Do i have the face of a liar? I was just defending myself so my goodie-oodie-boodie-frienderino didn't vote to lynch me like an asshole, now, if we suspect anyone, it should be paperplayer, he's acting extremely paranoid, while i haven't been giving too many fucks this game.

What a defense! You have me convinced you're not Mafia now!


/sarcasm

[The Wizard of Off]

Im going to change my vote to nien hes much more suspicious then paperplayer

[Julia Pseudo]

PaperPlayerX is highly suspicious after the PMs he sent. Let's lynch him.

[Julia Pseudo]

Actually, Nien is much more suspicious.

[MistakesWereMade]

PLEASE DON'T LYNCH ME

[Bomber57]

MAYBE IT'D BLOODY HELP IF YOU TOLD US WHY YOU THINK THEY ARE SUSPICIOUS.

I swear I am about to make a fucking rule that you should elaborate goddammit.

[Ignoritus]

PLEASE DON'T LYNCH ME

Oh, ok. Changing my vote to qig

[Ignoritus]

lol jk. no lynch nien still.

[qig]

MAYBE IT'D BLOODY HELP IF YOU TOLD US WHY YOU THINK THEY ARE SUSPICIOUS.

I swear I am about to make a fucking rule that you should elaborate goddammit.

maybe you should read the thread where multiple people have explained why we think nien is suspisious.

[MistakesWereMade]

Sorry for my sudden outburst, it's just that the only suspicion i have on me is the fact that igno claimed that i told him something on steam? Why would i even do that?

[Ignoritus]

Sorry for my sudden outburst, it's just that the only suspicion i have on me is the fact that igno claimed that i told him something on steam? Why would i even do that?

Even if we pretend for a moment that you didn't roleclaim Miller (lol), qig says the Sheriff called you out.

Know who the last person the Sheriff called out was?

Fallingsnow

qig's already proven his credibility. Can you prove yours?

[Bomber57]

MAYBE IT'D BLOODY HELP IF YOU TOLD US WHY YOU THINK THEY ARE SUSPICIOUS.

I swear I am about to make a fucking rule that you should elaborate goddammit.

maybe you should read the thread where multiple people have explained why we think nien is suspisious.

Oh...sorry.

Alright then.

[MacheTheFerret]

Alright, let's get this quote train rolling:

PaperPlayerX is highly suspicious after the PMs he sent. Let's lynch him.

I mean, you DID change your vote to Nien (who I will also change my vote to lynch, sorry Little Boo), but why were you so sudden to want to lynch me even after you said that you trusted me and that I, like you asked, did NOT reveal your role to the public? Suspicious...

Sorry for my sudden outburst, it's just that the only suspicion i have on me is the fact that igno claimed that i told him something on steam? Why would i even do that?

Even if we pretend for a moment that you didn't roleclaim Miller (lol), qig says the Sheriff called you out.

Know who the last person the Sheriff called out was?

Fallingsnow

qig's already proven his credibility. Can you prove yours?

Just because the Sheriff called out the Arsonist doesn't mean he'll instantaneously call out another Mafia. For that to happen, you would need to have a coincidence to occur.

Sorry for my sudden outburst, it's just that the only suspicion i have on me is the fact that igno claimed that i told him something on steam? Why would i even do that?

I can list 3 good reasons at to why you would do that:
1. You're a Mafioso desperate to stay alive, and your attempts to make other people look paranoid (like me) are desperate as well.
2. You're a Townie desperate to stay alive, but you are making yourself look suspicious in the process despite all your hard work to convince us you aren't Mafia
3. You aren't arsed to use #smbxgames.

I'm lynching PaperPlayerX

First, explain why, and second, reconsider your action.

[Ignoritus]

Just because the Sheriff called out the Arsonist doesn't mean he'll instantaneously call out another Mafia. For that to happen, you would need to have a coincidence to occur.

But he DID call out another Mafia. Read qig's post.

[Sevennights]

I'm lynching nien

[Julia Pseudo]

@Jacob9300Shadow:
Make sure you put your vote in bold red or else it won't count.