Page 2 of 3
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2017 1:10 pm
by arcade999
Supershroom wrote:arcade999 wrote:It's actually really pretty hard when you are new here and get exposed to criticisme for the first time.I also guess some persons may find this too hard and stressful, so they stop and never shows up aigain, and it could explain why you see tons of little accounts to goomba or shy guy grade, cuz they won't came back. I know it cuz it happened to me when I was new.
This is not our fault usually? They just don't come back because they're in fact not excited enough about the level designer to fully commit to a project and to contribute to the other parts of the community and to become an active user overall. There are people who will well-intentionedly evaluate your work, and in nearly all cases the criticism is fine. From my knowledge there's been barely cases where a genuinely committed user was turned away by awful or hostile criticism.
Bowser 1000 wrote:It is my art and design.
Ultimately nobody can force you to listen, but deliberately ignoring responses and trying to make blandness a selling-point is just cheeky from you.
You seems to misunderstand what I mean! The problem is not that it's "your fault", I not even pointing accusating anyone. Just saying that some people can find hard and stressful to hear all that criticisme for the first time, like me when I was a new user.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2017 1:13 pm
by ElectriKong
Bowser 1000 wrote:Supershroom wrote:arcade999 wrote:It's actually really pretty hard when you are new here and get exposed to criticisme for the first time.I also guess some persons may find this too hard and stressful, so they stop and never shows up aigain, and it could explain why you see tons of little accounts to goomba or shy guy grade, cuz they won't came back. I know it cuz it happened to me when I was new.
This is not our fault usually? They just don't come back because they're in fact not excited enough about the level designer to fully commit to a project and to contribute to the other parts of the community and to become an active user overall. There are people who will well-intentionedly evaluate your work, and in nearly all cases the criticism is fine. From my knowledge there's been barely cases where a genuinely committed user was turned away by awful or hostile criticism.
Bowser 1000 wrote:It is my art and design.
Ultimately nobody can force you to listen, but deliberately ignoring responses and trying to make blandness a selling-point is just cheeky from you.
You are very mean
You will be banned from playing my episode and like i said i have not yet added custom graphics then it will be better
No he isn't, and you cannot force anyone to not play your episode unless you don't publicly release it, which would ultimately mean no one can play it.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Wed Apr 12, 2017 2:12 pm
by Snessy the duck
Bowser 1000 wrote:Supershroom wrote:arcade999 wrote:It's actually really pretty hard when you are new here and get exposed to criticisme for the first time.I also guess some persons may find this too hard and stressful, so they stop and never shows up aigain, and it could explain why you see tons of little accounts to goomba or shy guy grade, cuz they won't came back. I know it cuz it happened to me when I was new.
This is not our fault usually? They just don't come back because they're in fact not excited enough about the level designer to fully commit to a project and to contribute to the other parts of the community and to become an active user overall. There are people who will well-intentionedly evaluate your work, and in nearly all cases the criticism is fine. From my knowledge there's been barely cases where a genuinely committed user was turned away by awful or hostile criticism.
Bowser 1000 wrote:It is my art and design.
Ultimately nobody can force you to listen, but deliberately ignoring responses and trying to make blandness a selling-point is just cheeky from you.
You are very mean
You will be banned from playing my episode and like i said i have not yet added custom graphics then it will be better
Umm... How was he being mean at all? For the last time, we're not being mean to you, we're trying to let you know what you could improve on so you can become a better designer. Also, as King of Eternity said, how are you going to ban us from playing your episode? Also, custom GFX doesn't automatically make a project better.
Also, about the screenshots, they look really bland and spammy, and the 3rd screen literally has nothing in it. I know it's your design and style, but that doesn't mean you can't improve on it.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sun Apr 16, 2017 12:55 am
by Brantonio16
Bowser 1000 wrote:Supershroom wrote:arcade999 wrote:It's actually really pretty hard when you are new here and get exposed to criticisme for the first time.I also guess some persons may find this too hard and stressful, so they stop and never shows up aigain, and it could explain why you see tons of little accounts to goomba or shy guy grade, cuz they won't came back. I know it cuz it happened to me when I was new.
This is not our fault usually? They just don't come back because they're in fact not excited enough about the level designer to fully commit to a project and to contribute to the other parts of the community and to become an active user overall. There are people who will well-intentionedly evaluate your work, and in nearly all cases the criticism is fine. From my knowledge there's been barely cases where a genuinely committed user was turned away by awful or hostile criticism.
Bowser 1000 wrote:It is my art and design.
Ultimately nobody can force you to listen, but deliberately ignoring responses and trying to make blandness a selling-point is just cheeky from you.
You are very mean
You will be banned from playing my episode and like i said i have not yet added custom graphics then it will be better
I always wondered why old users are usually very mean to new users, I mean of course we need to handle a critic but being mean with someone just because of how he works, makes new users leave to never come back. (Of course I don't refer to every old users, I know some of them aren't like that)
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sun Apr 16, 2017 1:49 am
by loop
Brantonio16 wrote:Bowser 1000 wrote:Supershroom wrote:
This is not our fault usually? They just don't come back because they're in fact not excited enough about the level designer to fully commit to a project and to contribute to the other parts of the community and to become an active user overall. There are people who will well-intentionedly evaluate your work, and in nearly all cases the criticism is fine. From my knowledge there's been barely cases where a genuinely committed user was turned away by awful or hostile criticism.
Ultimately nobody can force you to listen, but deliberately ignoring responses and trying to make blandness a selling-point is just cheeky from you.
You are very mean
You will be banned from playing my episode and like i said i have not yet added custom graphics then it will be better
I always wondered why old users are usually very mean to new users, I mean of course we need to handle a critic but being mean with someone just because of how he works, makes new users leave to never come back. (Of course I don't refer to every old users, I know some of them aren't like that)
There is a difference between being mean and constructive criticism.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sun Apr 16, 2017 6:08 am
by kr4k1n
Brantonio16 wrote:
I always wondered why old users are usually very mean to new users, I mean of course we need to handle a critic but being mean with someone just because of how he works, makes new users leave to never come back. (Of course I don't refer to every old users, I know some of them aren't like that)
I was wondering when somebody would finally point this out, I've always wondered why that is sometimes true.
As for the episode itself, it's pretty decent enough for your very first one, and at least it doesn't have complete enemy spam like other episodes do.
Bowser 1000 wrote:You are very mean
You will be banned from playing my episode and like i said i have not yet added custom graphics then it will be better
Maybe you should take a break from all of this by doing something else and just ignore the people who are annoying you?
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sun Apr 16, 2017 12:36 pm
by arcade999
We are really getting off topic, but before closing this discussion, I agree, it can be really stressful for new users to get all that criticisme one shot. The thing is then, old users are trying to help to improve the episode, even if, some can be means.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Fri Apr 28, 2017 10:54 am
by Bowser 1000
updated the original post with the new beta testers! also 2 new levels done since post
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Fri Apr 28, 2017 7:17 pm
by kr4k1n
You spelled some users' names wrong.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Fri Apr 28, 2017 8:29 pm
by FanofSMBX
What kind of graphics are you needing? What you want may be in the SMBX CGFX Cloud.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sat May 06, 2017 7:44 pm
by GianaSistersfan64
Well... You need a levels designer
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sun May 07, 2017 6:53 am
by Snessy the duck
GianaSistersfan64 wrote:Well... You need a levels designer
What?
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sun May 07, 2017 12:28 pm
by GianaSistersfan64
Snessy the duck wrote:GianaSistersfan64 wrote:Well... You need a levels designer
What?
I mean his levels are pretty strange. The Extra block are too close at the ground and he added too many Goombas.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2017 10:48 am
by mariosonicgamer556
Jesus Christ no need to be so harsh towards him. But I have to agree the episode needs alot of improvements. There is alot of enemy and item abuse and barely no BGO placement. Some of the levels are too linear and dull. I have nothing against anyone who uses vanilla graphics there whole episode. But that's what makes this episode unique because you rarely see episodes like this good job. But there is alot of clash in it. Like mixing smb3 with smw. They do not mix at all unless done right. And work on the coin placement. I hope you improve at your skills at level making.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Wed Dec 20, 2017 11:07 am
by Cedur
mariosonicgamer556 wrote:bump
Also in response to the bump: This attempt at a project was just pitiful, so the sarcastic reactions weren't even that bad in comparison, just expressing disapproval, I've witnessed a lot more destructive stuff, and OP's reactions were just hilariously immature
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Fri Dec 22, 2017 10:21 am
by xDestroy
Cedur wrote:This attempt at a project was just pitiful
LIES! NO ONE WOULD EVER HAVE THE ART AND PASION OF BOWSER 100! HE IS THE BEST LEVEL DESIGNER AND VANILLA MASTER IN THE ENTIRE UNIVERSE! WE NEED TO VOTE HIM FOR PRESIDENT FOR THIS AMAZING PROJECT! YOU SHALL BE BANNED FROM PLAYING HIS EPISODE! [quote="Review"]999999999999999999999999/10 IGN![/quote]
His name should be crafted in stone.[/size]
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sat Dec 23, 2017 7:33 am
by Kley
xDestroy wrote:Cedur wrote:This attempt at a project was just pitiful
LIES! NO ONE WOULD EVER HAVE THE ART AND PASION OF BOWSER 100! HE IS THE BEST LEVEL DESIGNER AND VANILLA MASTER IN THE ENTIRE UNIVERSE! WE NEED TO VOTE HIM FOR PRESIDENT FOR THIS AMAZING PROJECT! YOU SHALL BE BANNED FROM PLAYING HIS EPISODE! [quote="Review"]999999999999999999999999/10 IGN!
His name should be crafted in stone.[/size][/b][/quote]
This is obnoxious and the sarcasm isn't appreciated. Please don't be like this.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sat Dec 23, 2017 7:42 am
by Emral
im sorry to chime in when this is months old but
Cedur wrote:This attempt at a project was just pitiful, so the sarcastic reactions weren't even that bad in comparison
in what universe is this an appropriate response to anyone starting out with something? i'm not surprised he's been gone since april cause everyone here was just incredibly hostile towards him. half the "advice" in this thread is completely arbitrary and superficial as well. i thought people in this community were nicer than me, but i guess i was wrong.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sat Dec 23, 2017 4:15 pm
by Cedur
Enjl wrote:in what universe is this an appropriate response to anyone starting out with something? i'm not surprised he's been gone since april cause everyone here was just incredibly hostile towards him. half the "advice" in this thread is completely arbitrary and superficial as well. i thought people in this community were nicer than me, but i guess i was wrong.
yes there's been cases where the community has been trolly and uncivil in an unwarranted way. But where is the hostility here, especially
before the dude went immature and bullishly proclaimed "it's my art", like a 3-year-old would say "scribbling is my art"? Also I'm sure he would have left quickly no matter what, as many newcomers automatically do.
Re: Bowser's Revenge On The Mushroom Kingdom / NSMB3
Posted: Sat Dec 23, 2017 4:32 pm
by PixelPest
Cedur wrote:Also I'm sure he would have left quickly no matter what, as many newcomers automatically do.
I think this is not the point at all, and the opposite of it