Super Mario Bros. X Forums

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 9:33 am**

Raster wrote:why won't you remove his reviews? What's ironic is that Emral even said he was generous.

Removing all of one of the judges reviews would mean drastically changing the order of the results. Valtteri would have to recalculate everything again to get the correct average score. I think many of us would be really upset if that happened.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 9:36 am**

sezixor wrote:
Raster wrote:why won't you remove his reviews? What's ironic is that Emral even said he was generous.
Removing all of one of the judges reviews would mean drastically changing the order of the results. He would have to recalculate everything again to get the correct average score. I think many of us would be really upset if that happened.

On the other hand... It's rigged. Nothing else about it.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 9:48 am**

There is no other hand. If you fail to make a level that doesn't impress him, don't bitch about it.

Btw Emral told me that for the remaining levels there is no score lower than 5, and there's only 2x 5 left, but 3x 9 and 3x 10 left, iirc. Some of you might interest that.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 9:50 am**

Kyo, you don't understand what its like to hear what Emral has to say about my level. Just don't...

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 9:56 am**

He made a joke about the tileset. He didn't subtract any points for it. Apparently you don't understand it.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 10:01 am**

Kyo wrote:He made a joke about the tileset. He didn't subtract any points for it. Apparently you don't understand it.

You're not the judge. It's not like if you can tell.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 10:05 am**

Kyo wrote:He made a joke about the tileset. He didn't subtract any points for it. Apparently you don't understand it.

Even know it is a Joke, it isn't 100% Understandable to most of the Members out there especially if it is related to "Scores". Sure, I made a little joke too on a few Levels but that is just related to something else and not the Scores.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 10:07 am**

RoundPiplup wrote:
Kyo wrote:He made a joke about the tileset. He didn't subtract any points for it. Apparently you don't understand it.
You're not the judge. It's not like if you can tell.

Surprisingly I have the capability to differentiate seriousness from sarcasm. He was obviously being sarcastic.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 10:08 am**

Forget this. I'm just going to wait and see what happens later before someone starts to make me go over something like what happened to Blueoak. And no, I don't believe it.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 10:31 am**

So there is that drama again, eh...-.-

I think only, that Emral shouldn't round them up or down, because people can get up or down many places in a contest that uses so small deciamls in score, because of this. But e told he will do it like this, and no one seemed to complain about that back then.
But hating of that kind against one person, because he votes levels in a contest like this is just is gruesome, in my opinion. I guess i never will try to participate as a judge or anything, because i know what happens then, if i am doing it in a way, not everyone likes :-/.

I didn't even think of something like that would happen, to be honest, but now it did unfortunately...

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 10:36 am**

When you judge... You bring hate... That is it.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 10:59 am**

I removed Emral's review from every revealed level. Quite a few differences.

Spoiler: show

now let the downreps storm in

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 11:04 am**

Blueoak wrote:I removed Emral's review from every revealed level. Quite a few differences.
Spoiler: show
smbxxer - 0.125
fanofsmbx - 1.0875
vinyl - 1.7
sakke - 2.71875
little boo - 4.265
murphmario - 4.69825
crusher169 - 4.7375
dimitripowerseven - 4.99375
kchunming925364 - 5.2625
fireflowerhour - 5.05625
supermariobuilder16 - 5.4625
dollarluigi - 5.52625
henryrichard1234 - 5.31875
moemoe02 - 5.58125
pivot40channel - 5.59375
jangofred - 5.59375
8bitmushroom - 6.13125
mechdragon777 - 5.125
kingbowser112 - 5.7375
captainsyrup - 5.8125
schm2000 - 5.91875
litdude - 6.5125
aeon wisp - 6.51875
imaynotbehere4long - 6.58375
andregemeo23 - 7.06875
superwingedyoshi - 5.92375
blueoak - 7.12125
star - 6.98875
castlewars - 7.00625
midiguydp - 7.02125
mariogeek2 - 6.62375
thetoxicminecrafter1 - 7.2
roundpiplup - 7.21875
knux - 5.975
darkmatt - 7.775
gameclip477 - 7.41875
dragonmaster146 - 7.26375
beyond - 7.6
reghrhre - 7.16875
jarckius - 7.455
christian07 - 7.21625
gluigix - 7.07375
kep - 7.605
bulletbill43 - 7.90625
bryux - 7.65625
h2643 - 7.73375
hawkeyeone - 7.99375
now let the downreps storm in

Now that is the score that I was expecting a while ago as my first level being submitted to a contest like this.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 11:07 am**

Blueoak wrote:I removed Emral's review from every revealed level. Quite a few differences.
Spoiler: show
smbxxer - 0.125
fanofsmbx - 1.0875
vinyl - 1.7
sakke - 2.71875
little boo - 4.265
murphmario - 4.69825
crusher169 - 4.7375
dimitripowerseven - 4.99375
kchunming925364 - 5.2625
fireflowerhour - 5.05625
supermariobuilder16 - 5.4625
dollarluigi - 5.52625
henryrichard1234 - 5.31875
moemoe02 - 5.58125
pivot40channel - 5.59375
jangofred - 5.59375
8bitmushroom - 6.13125
mechdragon777 - 5.125
kingbowser112 - 5.7375
captainsyrup - 5.8125
schm2000 - 5.91875
litdude - 6.5125
aeon wisp - 6.51875
imaynotbehere4long - 6.58375
andregemeo23 - 7.06875
superwingedyoshi - 5.92375
blueoak - 7.12125
star - 6.98875
castlewars - 7.00625
midiguydp - 7.02125
mariogeek2 - 6.62375
thetoxicminecrafter1 - 7.2
roundpiplup - 7.21875
knux - 5.975
darkmatt - 7.775
gameclip477 - 7.41875
dragonmaster146 - 7.26375
beyond - 7.6
reghrhre - 7.16875
jarckius - 7.455
christian07 - 7.21625
gluigix - 7.07375
kep - 7.605
bulletbill43 - 7.90625
bryux - 7.65625
h2643 - 7.73375
hawkeyeone - 7.99375
now let the downreps storm in

The scores are still on a rising curve. It didn't really change that much. Tier 4 should be here soon.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 11:16 am**

If you actually read through the list, you'd notice that I haven't sorted anything. Everyone is still in the same positions, I haven't arranged it into score order and the places are very different if I was to do that.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 11:31 am**

Only Knux moves down and DarkMatt up a lot. But that's where the judges majorly disagreed with each other. There isn't any other severe change. If you remove the reviews of any other judge and leave Emral's reviews there, it would influence the list just as much, and if not, barely remarkably. This is just the natural influence of one judge's opinion. Nothing severe.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 11:32 am**

Kyo wrote:Only Knux moves down a lot. There isn't any other severe change. If you remove the reviews of any other judge and leave Emral's reviews there, it would influence the list just as much, and if not, barely remarkably. This is just the natural influence of one judge's opinion. Nothing severe.

I dunno, I'm pretty sure removing a 2/10 score on Blueoak's and Darkmatt's levels would be a pretty big change.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 11:33 am**

Bomber57 wrote:
Kyo wrote:Only Knux moves down a lot. There isn't any other severe change. If you remove the reviews of any other judge and leave Emral's reviews there, it would influence the list just as much, and if not, barely remarkably. This is just the natural influence of one judge's opinion. Nothing severe.
I dunno, I'm pretty sure removing a 2/10 score on Blueoak's and Darkmatt's levels would be a pretty big change.

Blueoak and Darkmatt's level would actually end up going in a higher tier. Too many biased stuff.

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 11:38 am**

First half of tier 4 for you!

Posted: **Mon Jul 28, 2014 11:41 am**

Valtteri wrote:First half of tier 4 for you!

will you post part 2 today for me since it's my birthday? <3

Super Mario Bros. X Forums

Level Contest 8: The Winner!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 3 Is Here!

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 4, Part 1

Re: Level Contest 8: Tier 4, Part 1