M4: 'The Best Mafia Game'

The Wizard of Off · Postby **The Wizard of Off** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 8:27 pm

does it not seem odd too anyone that little boo was killed right after he accused him of being jester,mafia,or a special?

The Wizard of Off · Postby **The Wizard of Off** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 8:28 pm

accused murphmario of being jester or mafia

Ignoritus · Postby **Ignoritus** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 8:36 pm

So Blue Dread claims to be in contact with the Sheriff. Which means that if either he or Murphmario is mafia, the other one almost assuredly is. It also means that we have no chance of lynching the sheriff if we lynch Blue Dread or Murphmario, since the only situation in which he would have reason to lie about having talked to the sheriff is the one in which he was actually a mafia. I don't know. I really don't buy that the Sheriff told him his role turn one, and we also now potentially gain extra information out of lynching him as well as having no chance of lynching our sheriff. I don't see how anyone else is a better option. I stand by my vote.

Postby **Shadow Yoshi** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 8:39 pm

A townsperson claim means nothing at this point, for what it's worth.

Postby **Shadow Yoshi** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 8:40 pm

Also, Sheriff, inspect Blue Dread right away if you haven't already.

The Wizard of Off · Postby **The Wizard of Off** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 8:42 pm

The Wizard of Off wrote:
Blue Dread wrote:
Little Boo wrote:Joey: Sorry, this is my first mafia, i'm not used to this yet :\

On Topic: I don't believe murphmario because odds are against him since he was a miller (a type of townsperson) in mafia 2 (he wasn't partaking in mafia 3) so i feel like he wouldn't be a townsperson in this mafia, I feel like he could be the vigilante, mafia, serial killer or a jester. If he is a serial killer it would be easy to tell because we wouldn't have another person die when day 1 finishes, he could be a vigilante (or any other special) he could be blue, if he IS a special he could be trying to hide it from the mafia that he is a special, he could be a mafia trying to hide from us, but most likely i feel that he is the jester or serial killer
No doubt. But are you sure we should lynch him tomorrow? If he really is the jester, one of us is risked to get killed!
maybe the sheriff could investigate murphmario then pm someone to say what he is so we still have the sheriff and we know who he is

maybe the sheriff was listening and told blue dread maybe he trusts him so we still have no idea if he could be lying

Postby **Shadow Yoshi** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 8:43 pm

Vigi should probably claim publically so we can get an alliance going, as he's probably the most useless special role. The Sheriff can then claim to the vigi, and we have almost two whole phases' worth of time before the vigi can possibly get killed (allowing for more strategic development).

Postby **Magna** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 8:51 pm

Guys, please let me prove to you that the sheriff wasn't wrong. Sheriff, as Joey said, inspect me tonight.

Postby **Shadow Yoshi** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:00 pm

We can't "let you prove" that because:

1. You're in the mafia, in which case that obviously won't work.
2. You're a normal townsperson, in which case you're not the best candidate for leading an alliance.
3. You're a special, in which case you should keep quiet about your role.
4. You're not only a special, but the vigi, in which case you should claim right now.

We also can't trust you until the Sheriff claims, and we can't have the Sheriff made public.

Semi-safety on Blue Dread. Not only is he a bit suspicious because he wants us to trust him without reason, but I also might not be around tomorrow to vote.

Postby **Shadow Yoshi** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:03 pm

Presumably without reason, at least. It wouldn't be a good idea to trust his "guys I know the Sheriff so trust me" reasoning. Once again, the only way that Blue Dread can be trusted is if the Sheriff claims publically, and we can't let that happen.

Postby **Shadow Yoshi** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:04 pm

Text log from tonight:

<TNTElsa> Joey
<TNTElsa> My only issue with the Vigi claiming himself is that he's presenting himself to the mafia
<TNTElsa> Your plans seem pretty careless
<Joey> i know that
<Joey> that's why i said "he's the most useless special" and "we still have two phases worth of time to strategize"
<Joey> because it's going to be almost 2 phases before the vigi dies
<Joey> and the vigi loses his power if the guy's innocent anyway
<Joey> qig: ping
<Joey> we need to know if the vigi gets notified when he uses a power
<Joey> because we can use that as a guilty/innocent seering
<Joey> there's also the chance the vigi won't die
<Joey> especially if the veteran protects him
<Joey> unless the serial killer kills him
<Joey> which he probably will

Ignoritus · Postby **Ignoritus** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:05 pm

Not to mention that if the Sheriff inspected Murphmario and he turned up green, why would the Sheriff then go to Blue Dread rather than Murphmario?

The Wizard of Off · Postby **The Wizard of Off** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:14 pm

I dont think we should lynch blue dread he so far he is our only lead so what if he is telling the truth then we lynch him we have no other lead

Postby **Magna** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:16 pm

The Wizard of Off wrote:I dont think we should lynch blue dread he so far he is our only lead so what if he is telling the truth then we lynch him we have no other lead

Plus, I know more than you expect. I may even know some roles of some of the members. I may be valuable at this moment in time and lynching me will blow your chances of using my intelligence.

Postby **Shadow Yoshi** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:17 pm

Blue Dread wrote:
The Wizard of Off wrote:I dont think we should lynch blue dread he so far he is our only lead so what if he is telling the truth then we lynch him we have no other lead
Plus, I know more than you expect. I may even know some roles of some of the members. I may be valuable at this moment in time and lynching me will blow your chances of using my intelligence.

So why not share your information? This is incredibly suspicious.

Postby **Murphmario** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:19 pm

I am not the godfather. I have no idea who is.

Postby **Magna** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:21 pm

Joey, why would you want me to share my intelligence, especially the sheriff, if you know what will happen to him if I do? This happened in mafia 2 also. I revealed the doctor and he died as a result of my foolishness. I won't make the same mistake again and it's best if I keep it to myself for now.

Besides, why would you want the sheriff revealed unless you want him purposely revealed for your own intentions? If you were a serial killer or a mafioso, you would intentionally as for someone's role, especially a sheriff's, so that you would kill him during the night.

I change my vote to Joey because I find him to be super suspicious to be wanting me to reveal a very valuable players role.

The Wizard of Off · Postby **The Wizard of Off** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:24 pm

Blue Dread wrote:Joey, why would you want me to share my intelligence, especially the sheriff, if you know what will happen to him if I do? This happened in mafia 2 also. I revealed the doctor and he died as a result of my foolishness. I won't make the same mistake again and it's best if I keep it to myself for now.

Besides, why would you want the sheriff revealed unless you want him purposely revealed for your own intentions? If you were a serial killer or a mafioso, you would intentionally as for someone's role, especially a sheriff's, so that you would kill him during the night.

I change my vote to Joey because I find him to be super suspicious to be wanting me to reveal a very valuable players role.

now that I think of it that way I also vote Joey

Bomber57 · Postby **Bomber57** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:27 pm

Blue Dread wrote:Joey, why would you want me to share my intelligence, especially the sheriff, if you know what will happen to him if I do? This happened in mafia 2 also. I revealed the doctor and he died as a result of my foolishness. I won't make the same mistake again and it's best if I keep it to myself for now.

Besides, why would you want the sheriff revealed unless you want him purposely revealed for your own intentions? If you were a serial killer or a mafioso, you would intentionally as for someone's role, especially a sheriff's, so that you would kill him during the night.

I change my vote to Joey because I find him to be super suspicious to be wanting me to reveal a very valuable players role.

You simpleton, he DOESN'T want the sheriff revealed because for him it'd be suicide. Both the mafia and SK would target him and the doctor couldn't protect both. Just because he is unsure of your claims of knowing the Sheriff doesn't make him suspicious.

You and many others are very trigger happy when it comes to accusing.

Postby **Magna** » Wed Aug 13, 2014 9:35 pm

Bomber57 wrote:
Blue Dread wrote:Joey, why would you want me to share my intelligence, especially the sheriff, if you know what will happen to him if I do? This happened in mafia 2 also. I revealed the doctor and he died as a result of my foolishness. I won't make the same mistake again and it's best if I keep it to myself for now.

Besides, why would you want the sheriff revealed unless you want him purposely revealed for your own intentions? If you were a serial killer or a mafioso, you would intentionally as for someone's role, especially a sheriff's, so that you would kill him during the night.

I change my vote to Joey because I find him to be super suspicious to be wanting me to reveal a very valuable players role.
You simpleton, he DOESN'T want the sheriff revealed because for him it'd be suicide. Both the mafia and SK would target him and the doctor couldn't protect both. Just because he is unsure of your claims of knowing the Sheriff doesn't make him suspicious.

You and many others are very trigger happy when it comes to accusing.

At least I'm not the one accusing people of past actions.

*Looks at Ignoritus and FallingSnow.*